Chapter 6: What Happened Before the Toast

I showed Ethan the message.
He read it once.
Then he set the phone down on the mattress without a word.
"Call her," he said.
I did.
Carol picked up on the second ring.
She was seventy-one years old and had never, in my entire memory, been anything other than direct.
"I've been sitting on this for five years," she said, before I could speak.
"And I've decided I'm done sitting on it."
"Aunt Carol.
What are you talking about?"
"The toast," she said.
"Your mother didn't write that on her own."
I felt something tighten in my chest.
"What do you mean?"
"There was a man at your wedding.
An old friend of the family.
Warren Hobbes.
He knew your father for years." She paused.
"He also knew Robert Calloway."
Ethan had gone very still beside me.
"Warren was the one who told your mother that Ethan was Robert's son," Carol said.
"The night before the wedding.
He came to the rehearsal dinner.
Pulled Linda aside.
Told her she needed to warn you."
"Warn me," I repeated.
"He told her the apple doesn't fall far from the tree.
That Ethan would do what his father did.
That she had a responsibility to say something before it was too late."
"And she believed him."
"She was frightened," Carol said.
"She'd watched your father suffer.
She didn't want that for you."
"She humiliated my husband in front of two hundred people."
"I know."
"Based on a story from a man who had thirty years of incorrect information."
"I know that too, Olivia."
I stood up from the bed.
I needed to move.
"Why didn't you stop her?" I asked.
"You were there."
A long pause.
"Because I didn't know until afterward.
She didn't tell me what Warren had said until the reception was already over.
By then —" Carol's voice dropped.
"By then the damage was done and your mother had convinced herself she'd done the right thing."
"Who is Warren Hobbes?" Ethan asked.
He said it clearly enough for Carol to hear.
"He was a creditor," Carol said.
"One of the people your father owed money to when the garage collapsed.
He was never repaid."
Ethan closed his eyes for one second.
"Because the payment went to Gerald.
My father paid the primary partner first."
"Warren didn't know that," Carol said.
"Or if he did, he didn't care.
He'd been carrying a grudge for twenty years.
And when he saw you at that rehearsal dinner —"
"He used my mother," I said.
"He used her fear," Carol said.
"Which is a different thing, but not a better one."
I stood at the window.
The same window Ethan had stood at an hour ago.
"Does Mom know this?" I asked.
"Does she know Warren drove her to do it?"
"I told her just now," Carol said.
"When she called me."
"How did she take it?"
Another pause.
This one was the kind that carried its own weight.
"She's not well, Olivia," Carol said quietly.
"I don't mean today.
I mean she's been struggling for a while.
Her health.
Her memory sometimes.
She's been alone in that house and too proud to say anything to you about it."
I turned from the window.
"What do you mean, her memory?"
"Nothing severe," Carol said quickly.
"But enough.
Enough that she holds onto old stories tighter than she should, because the old ones are the ones she still trusts." She paused.
"Warren told her something that fit a story she already believed.
She didn't question it because questioning it would have meant letting go of something she was still holding for your father."
The room was very quiet.
Ethan stood up and crossed to where I was standing.
He didn't say anything.
He just stood beside me.
"She needs to see a doctor," I said.
"A proper one."
May you like
"She needs someone to take her," Carol said.
I knew what that meant.