Spotlight

Chapter 5: The Call from Marcus

Bennett looked at the name on the screen.

Then at me.

"Do you want me to—"

"Answer it," I said.

He picked up and put it on speaker.

"Bennett." Marcus's voice was tight.

"Is my sister there?"

"She's here.

You're on speaker."

"Good." A breath.

"Eleanor called me forty minutes ago."

Neither of us spoke.

"She called you," I said finally.

"Tonight."

"While she was still at your house, I think.

Or just after she left.

She told me she'd been doing some protecting of her own and that I should know what kind of woman my sister really is."

"What did she say?" Bennett asked.

"She said Cara has been lying to you about your finances.

That she's been moving money without your knowledge.

That she has a separate account she's never told you about." A pause.

"She said she has documentation."

I stood up from the table.

"That is not true," I said.

"Marcus—"

"I know," he said.

"I told her I know exactly how you handle your money because you've talked to me about it for years.

I told her I'd seen your joint statements when you asked me to look at your mortgage refinancing last spring."

"What did she say to that?"

"She said I was covering for you.

She said families cover for each other and that I'd been doing it since before your wedding." Another pause.

"She also said that if I didn't encourage you to let Bennett see your personal finances independently, she was going to contact someone at his firm with what she had."

Bennett's hand had gone flat on the table.

"She threatened you," he said.

"She made a suggestion," Marcus said carefully.

"The kind that's meant to sound like concern."

I turned and looked at Bennett.

His jaw was set.

The expression on his face was one I recognized — it was the look he got in depositions when the other side had just shown their hand and didn't know it yet.

"Marcus," Bennett said.

"Do you still have her number on your phone?"

"Yes."

"Don't delete it.

Don't respond to her again tonight.

I need you to save the call log."

"Already done." A pause.

"Bennett, I want to say something, and I want you to hear it from me directly." Marcus's voice shifted — quieter, more careful.

"I have watched my sister love you for seven years.

Five married, two before that.

I have never once seen her be anything but honest with you.

Whatever Eleanor is doing — and I think you know what she's doing — it has nothing to do with your finances or your marriage.

It has to do with the fact that she can't accept that you chose someone she didn't choose for you."

The candle nearest to me had burned low.

The wax pooled at the base.

"Thank you," Bennett said.

"I'll call you tomorrow."

The line went quiet.

Bennett set the phone down.

"She called him while she was still in the car," I said.

"She left here and the first thing she did was call my brother."

"She's not finished," Bennett said.

"Tonight wasn't the end of something.

It was the opening move."

I looked at him.

"She said she has documentation," I said.

"About our finances."

"There is no documentation," Bennett said.

"Because there's nothing to document."

"I know that.

You know that.

But if she sends something to your firm—"

"Then we get ahead of it." He was already thinking it through — I could see it the way I'd seen it a hundred times, the way his mind shifted into a different gear.

"I'm going to call Richard in the morning.

Tonight, I'm going to make a list of everything she said, everything she did, and the exact sequence of it.

Marcus has the call log.

We have the text she sent Richard.

We have the photograph and the story behind it."

"Bennett."

"She's not going to do this to you," he said.

"She's not going to do this to us."

I believed him.

But later, when he was in his office writing down the timeline and I was clearing the table alone, I found something tucked under Eleanor's plate.

A business card.

It didn't belong to anyone at the table tonight.

The name on it was a woman I had never heard of.

May you like

Below the name, in Eleanor's handwriting, were four words.

*She already knows everything.*

Related Stories

Other posts