Spotlight

Chapter 7: What Sarah Started

David was already typing when I put my hand on his arm.

"Don't," I said.

He looked up.

"Not tonight," I said.

"Whatever you're about to say to her — don't say it tonight.

You'll say it wrong."

He held the phone for another moment.

Then he set it face-down on the table.

Chloe had lifted her head.

Her eyes were red.

"She's going to be angry," she said quietly.

"Your mother?" David asked.

"She thinks — " Chloe stopped.

"She's been telling me for two years that you were going to stop choosing me once you really settled into this marriage.

That once things got serious, I'd become inconvenient."

David closed his eyes briefly.

"And you believed her," he said.

"She's my mom."

"I know." He exhaled.

"But she was wrong."

Chloe looked at me.

"She said things about you specifically.

That you resented me.

That you wanted to push me out."

"I know what she said," I told her.

"Some of it found its way back to me."

"None of it was true, was it."

"No."

She pressed her hands flat on the table.

"I set you up today because I wanted proof that I came first.

That's why I positioned myself near the stairs.

I wanted Dad to have to choose, in front of everyone, and I wanted him to choose me." She looked at her father.

"But then you gave her that ultimatum and she just — left.

She didn't beg you to believe her.

She just left." Chloe's voice thinned.

"And I watched you watch her go, and I realized you didn't look like you'd won anything."

David looked at his hands.

"I didn't," he said.

Sarah called back.

The phone lit up on the table, screen-up where they all could see it — *Sarah* — buzzing steadily.

David reached for it.

"I'll handle it," Chloe said.

Both of us looked at her.

"She'll twist whatever you say," Chloe said to her father.

"She does it every time.

Let me talk to her."

"Chloe —"

"I'm the one who told her things." She picked up the phone before David could stop her, accepted the call, and held it to her ear.

"Mom." She kept her voice steady.

"I need you to stop texting Dad."

Sarah's voice carried faintly from the phone — elevated, quick.

"Nothing was done to me," Chloe said.

"Mom.

Listen to me.

I found out tonight that I have been carrying your version of this family in my head for two years, and it doesn't match reality.

I did something today that I'm not proud of."

More from Sarah.

Faster.

"That's not what happened." Chloe's jaw tightened.

"Stop.

Mom.

Stop defending me.

I'm not asking you to defend me.

I'm asking you to listen." A pause.

"I told you things she said privately.

I shouldn't have done that.

You used those things.

I let you."

The faint voice on the other end changed tone.

Chloe closed her eyes.

"No.

I know you love me.

That's not what this is about." Her voice steadied further.

"But you've been asking me to spy on this household for two years and calling it concern.

And I did it.

Because I love you and I wanted to make you feel better.

But I hurt someone tonight — someone who has been trying, this whole time — and I need to fix that.

I can't keep doing this."

Silence from the phone.

"I'll call you tomorrow," Chloe said.

"Goodnight, Mom."

She ended the call.

She set the phone back on the table and pushed it toward her father.

Then she looked at me.

"Will you tell me about the baby?" she asked quietly.

"If you're willing.

What would it have been — a boy or girl?"

Something moved through my chest.

"It was too early to know," I said.

She nodded.

"I'm sorry it happened."

"So am I."

Barbara set a cup of tea in front of me without asking whether I wanted it.

I wrapped my hands around it.

We stayed at that table for another hour.

Chloe asked questions — careful, real ones.

David answered things he'd never said out loud before, about the guilt he still carried from his divorce, about how that guilt had bent his judgment without him realizing it.

Barbara said very little, but she stayed.

It was, I thought, the most honest the four of us had ever been in the same room.

I didn't know yet if it was enough to build something on.

But when I drove home that night — I was the last to leave, which surprised me — my bracelet was back on my wrist.

David had clasped it there himself, quietly, at the door.

He hadn't asked if I'd let him.

He'd simply picked it up and waited to see if I'd pull back.

I hadn't.

But in the morning, there was still the matter of Sarah.

And what she'd asked Chloe to do — and for how long — was going to need to be addressed somewhere more formal than a kitchen table.

Barbara had already said so, very quietly, as I put on my coat.

"This didn't start with today," she'd said.

"And it won't end here."

She was right.

May you like

I already knew it.

I just wasn't sure yet how many things were going to have to break before we could start rebuilding.

Related Stories

Other posts