Chapter 10: Thursday

Daniel arrived at Ruth's office with a solicitor I didn't recognize — a tall man in a dark suit who introduced himself as Mr.
Gareth Soames and then said very little for the first twenty minutes, which I suspected was strategy.
Daniel had not expected Vivienne to be there.
He stopped in the doorway when he saw her.
His expression did exactly what I'd expected it to do — went through denial, recalculation, and something close to fear in the span of about two seconds.
Then he arranged his face and came in.
'This is unusual,' Soames said, looking at Ruth.
'Ms.
Marsh is here voluntarily,' Ruth said.
'She has information relevant to this matter and has waived her right to separate representation for the purpose of today's discussion.
She has her own solicitor on standby by phone.' Ruth gestured to the chairs.
'Please sit down.'
Daniel sat.
He didn't look at me.
He looked at the table.
'I'd like to begin,' Ruth said, 'by confirming what is now formally documented.' She opened a folder.
'The attempted beneficiary change on the company life policy, dated three days before Mr.
Whitmore's departure.
The seven under-threshold transfers from the joint marital account totaling four thousand, one hundred and forty pounds.
The refinancing clause inserted into the joint mortgage agreement.
The property company registered in Mr.
Whitmore's name and that of his brother, Derek Keane.
The second joint account opened with a forged signature.
And the sixteen payments to Ms.
Fiona Hayward over twelve months.'
Soames started to speak.
Ruth raised one hand slightly.
'I haven't finished,' she said.
Soames stopped.
'Ms.
Marsh has provided correspondence from Mr.
Whitmore's personal email account confirming his awareness of each of the above arrangements.
The forensic accountant's written report is in this folder.
A formal referral has been made to the financial fraud division, and they have confirmed receipt.' Ruth closed the folder.
'If Mr.
Whitmore would like to respond, now would be the appropriate time.'
Daniel was looking at Vivienne.
'You went through my emails,' he said.
'You gave me the password,' Vivienne said quietly.
'On the ship.
You told me to book a restaurant.'
'That was—'
'You handed it to me yourself, Daniel.'
He looked back at the table.
'My client,' Soames said carefully, 'would like to understand the scope of the referral before making any—'
'The scope is what it is,' Ruth said.
'The referral is already made.
That process is independent of what happens in this room today.'
Daniel's jaw worked.
'You don't know what you've done,' he said to me.
For the first time that morning, he looked directly at me.
'I didn't do anything,' I said.
'I read documents I had every right to read.
I called my bank.
I called your HR department.
I hired a solicitor.' I met his eyes.
'You did the rest yourself.'
'Helen—'
'The house stays,' Ruth said crisply.
'The attempt to invoke the dissolution clause is being challenged.
Given the forged signature, the challenge has a very strong basis.' She looked at Soames.
'I trust your client has informed you of the account-opening document.'
Soames had clearly not been fully informed of the account-opening document.
He covered it well, but not well enough.
'I'll need time with my client,' Soames said.
'You have thirty minutes,' Ruth said.
'The documents aren't going anywhere.'
Daniel stood up.
Soames put a hand on his arm — a brief, professional gesture that said *not yet.* Daniel sat back down.
'I can explain the account,' Daniel said.
'You'll have the opportunity to explain it,' Ruth said evenly.
'To the appropriate people.'
'Helen.' His voice cracked slightly.
Not from remorse, I thought.
From the specific realization that he had built a careful structure and left one detail incomplete — the insurance papers — and that one incomplete detail had caused me to look.
And looking had unraveled everything.
'I never meant for things to go this far.'
'What did you mean for them to go?' I asked.
He didn't answer.
'I need to know,' I said.
'Not for Ruth.
Not for the file.
I need to know, from you, what you meant to happen to me and three newborn daughters while you started your tidy new life.'
The room was very quiet.
'I thought you'd be fine,' he said finally.
I looked at him for a long time.
'Of course you did,' I said.
I turned to Ruth.
'I think thirty minutes is generous.
But that's your call.'
Ruth nodded once.
'We'll reconvene shortly.'
Daniel and Soames moved to the waiting room.
Through the glass panel in the door, I could see Soames speaking rapidly, his hands moving.
Daniel sat with his elbows on his knees and his face in his hands.
Vivienne watched him through the glass for a moment.
Then she turned away.
'Are you all right?' she asked me.
'I think so,' I said.
'You?'
She was quiet for a moment.
'I keep thinking about the sign,' she said.
'The one you made.
*Welcome home, Daddy.*'
'I'd been working on it for a week,' I said.
'The girls' handprints on the back.
I thought it would make him happy.'
Vivienne looked at the glass panel.
Daniel still had his face in his hands.
'He told me you'd stopped loving him years ago,' she said quietly.
I didn't respond to that.
May you like
'I know,' she said.
'I know he did.'