Chapter 9: The Lawyer and the Folder

Dana knew a veteran's rights attorney named Claire Moss, who operated out of a small practice forty minutes from us.
Dana knew her because Claire had represented Dana's first husband in a wrongful termination case eight years ago, and Dana had a long memory for people who fought hard and won.
Claire Moss turned out to be a compact, unhurried woman in her late fifties who spoke in short, complete sentences and took notes with a fountain pen in a small leather notebook.
She had the manner of someone who had sat across from large institutions for so long that she no longer found them frightening.
We sat in her office the following morning — Martin, myself, Dana by the wall — and laid out everything.
Tully's call.
Whitford.
The infirmary.
The two hours.
The complaint Breslin's family was preparing.
Claire listened without interrupting.
When Martin finished, she set down her pen.
"First question," she said.
"Do you have any documentation of the base physician's assessment that night?
Written record, discharge note, anything?"
"Colonel Hargrove's office can provide it," Martin said.
"He flagged the case for follow-up.
There should be a file."
"Good.
That establishes the concussion and the cognitive state.
That's our foundation." She tapped her notebook.
"Second question.
Private Reyes — have you made contact?"
"Tully sent her name last night.
Martin called her this morning." I glanced at Martin.
"She'll talk," Martin said.
"She's frightened but she'll talk.
She said she documented it in her personal notes that night — she keeps a log.
She was worried enough to write it down."
Claire's expression didn't change, but her pen moved.
"Personal contemporary notes from a witness present in the infirmary," she said.
"Written the same night.
That is significant." She looked at Martin.
"And Whitford — does he know anyone has connected him to this?"
"Not yet."
"Good.
We want it that way until we're ready." She folded her hands on the desk.
"Here's what I need you to understand.
If Breslin's family files a formal complaint claiming Martin was the aggressor and they produce a signed statement as evidence, we will challenge that statement on the grounds of cognitive impairment at the time of signing.
We have the physician's assessment, Reyes's contemporary notes, and Tully as a witness to the circumstances of the signing.
That is not a weak position."
"But?" Dana said from the wall.
Claire looked at her without annoyance.
"But the signed document exists.
We don't know what it says.
We need to know what it says before they use it, not after."
"Can you get it?" I asked.
"I can request it through proper channels.
It will take time." She paused.
"There is a faster way.
If Whitford can be compelled to produce the folder voluntarily, through his chain of command, before Breslin's family makes a formal move — we see the document first.
We control the response."
"Colonel Hargrove," Martin said.
"Would he cooperate?"
Martin thought.
"He called Renee directly.
He flagged the case.
He's not protecting Breslin's side in this."
"Then make that call today," Claire said.
"Before the week is out.
Because you're right that the complaint is coming soon, and once it's filed formally, our options narrow." She looked at Martin directly.
"You defended someone who had no protection.
Someone tried to take advantage of the moments when you had no protection.
We are going to make that very clear."
Martin nodded once.
We stood to leave.
At the door, Claire touched my arm briefly.
"He came home," she said quietly.
"We're going to make sure it stays that way."
That evening, Colonel Hargrove agreed to make the inquiry.
He said he would have an answer by morning.
By midnight, he called back.
"The folder exists," he said.
"Whitford logged it as a voluntary statement, submitted by the servicemember.
But there's something else."
I pressed the phone tighter.
"Reyes wasn't the only witness who was uncomfortable.
There's a second name in the infirmary log that night.
Someone who signed in as a visitor and signed out twelve minutes later."
May you like
"Who?"
"The name on the log," Hargrove said, "is Breslin."