Chapter 4: The Woman He Chose Instead

Priya Mehta's office was on the fourteenth floor of a glass building on Bay Street.
She was smaller than I expected — fine-boned, with reading glasses pushed up into dark hair and a desk covered in color-coded folders.
She shook my hand once, firm and brief, and pointed to the chair across from her.
"I've read everything Daniel sent," she said.
"And I've reviewed the Hayes prenuptial agreement and the trust instrument.
Before we discuss strategy, I need to ask you one direct question."
"Go ahead."
"Is there anything in your marriage that Alexander could use against you?
Any conduct, any record, any relationship he could point to in court?"
"No."
She studied me for a moment.
"You answered that quickly."
"Because I've been answering for it my entire marriage," I said.
"I gave up a promotion in 2020 to manage our household because he said it was better for Grace.
I turned down a conference in London because he didn't want me traveling without him.
I attended every dinner, every family event, every function his mother required.
I was exactly what he needed me to be." I paused.
"The only thing Alexander can say about my conduct is that I left."
Priya wrote something on the yellow pad in front of her.
"Then we're in a strong position." She set her pen down.
"The secondary clause is enforceable.
His father's estate attorney confirmed the notarization this morning.
Alexander's legal team will challenge it, but their strongest argument — that the neglect wasn't legally established — collapses the moment we enter the hospital timeline and the preschool's incident report into evidence."
"The preschool filed a report?"
"Standard procedure when a child leaves the grounds unaccompanied and is subsequently injured." Priya slid a folder across the desk.
"The report names Alexander as the responsible parent listed for collection that day.
His signature is on the registration form."
I opened the folder.
His handwriting was right there.
Familiar.
Careful.
The same hand that had signed our marriage certificate.
"He's going to fight this," I said.
"Yes.
And I want you prepared for how." She folded her hands.
"His first move will be to challenge your standing.
He'll argue the trust was a family asset and that your departure — leaving the marital home without mediation — constitutes abandonment under Illinois family law."
"Can he make that argument hold?"
"Not well.
You left after documented marital misconduct on his part.
The dinner.
The necklace.
The social media post during the accident." She tilted her head.
"Did you screenshot Madison's post before it was taken down?"
I reached into my bag and slid my phone across the desk.
The screenshot was saved the night Grace d\*ed, the timestamp visible in the corner of the screen.
Priya looked at it for a long moment.
She didn't say anything.
She took a photo of my phone with her own.
"His second move," she continued, "will be to use the pregnancy.
Olivia's child — if the paternity is confirmed — creates a competing claim on Alexander's personal assets, which his team will use to argue financial strain and delay proceedings."
"He knew about the pregnancy two months ago," I said.
"While Grace was still alive.
While we were still married and living in the same house."
"Can you prove he knew?"
I thought of Catherine.
Of the careful way she had said: he's known for two months.
"I may have a witness," I said.
Priya looked up.
"Alexander's family lawyer called me the night before I came here.
She's the one who told me about the trust and about the Thursday board meeting." I paused.
"She told me Alexander knew about Olivia's pregnancy before Grace d\*ed."
The room went still.
"Catherine Reeves called you directly." Priya said it slowly, as if placing the words somewhere precise.
"And she told you Alexander was aware of the pregnancy while your daughter was alive."
"Yes."
Priya picked up her pen again.
She didn't write anything.
She just held it.
"If Catherine Reeves is willing to give a statement," she said, "this case changes shape entirely.
We are no longer arguing over a trust clause.
We are presenting a pattern — a man who maintained a secret relationship, concealed a pregnancy, neglected his child, and then attempted to dissolve her trust fund within a week of her death." She set the pen down.
"That is not a divorce case.
That is a misconduct case.
And the clause your father-in-law wrote covers exactly that."
My phone buzzed on the desk between us.
A Chicago number.
Not Alexander's.
Madison's.
I looked at Priya.
She gave a small nod.
I answered.
"Emily." Madison's voice was stretched tight.
"I know you're in Toronto.
I need you to listen to me.
Please."
"I'm listening."
"Alexander found out about the lawyer.
About Catherine." A breath.
"He called a family meeting this morning.
He's telling everyone you're trying to steal from the estate.
He's telling them Catherine acted out of personal bitterness because he passed her over for a partnership two years ago." She stopped.
"Emily, he's building a story.
He's been building it since you left.
And our mother is helping him."
I looked at the folder on Priya's desk.
"Madison," I said carefully.
"Were you there when he found out about Olivia's pregnancy?
Two months ago?"
Silence on the line.
A long silence.
May you like
"Yes," she said.
"I was there."