Chapter 9: What Was Left to Decide

Tom slept in the guest room again that night.
But in the morning, when I came downstairs at six, he was already at the kitchen table with a cup of coffee and a legal pad, and there was a second cup waiting on the counter that he hadn't presumed to put in front of me.
I picked it up myself and sat across from him.
The legal pad had two columns.
One said *Mediation*.
The other said *Counselling*.
He pushed it toward me without saying anything.
I looked at it for a long moment.
"You looked these up last night."
"I couldn't sleep."
"Which one do you think we need?"
He met my eyes.
"Honestly?
Both.
In that order."
I looked at the columns.
Names of practices.
Phone numbers.
A few notes in his handwriting — *specialize in infidelity*, *also work with blended families*.
Blended families.
The phrase landed somewhere in my chest and stayed there.
"If I agree to try," I said, "it doesn't mean I've forgiven you."
"I know."
"And it doesn't mean I've decided about Daniel permanently.
That needs its own conversation.
With a professional."
"I know that too."
"And I'm going to need complete honesty from you.
Not honesty when it's comfortable.
Not honesty when you've figured out how to phrase it.
Real honesty, even when it makes you look terrible."
"Yes," he said.
"All of it.
Yes."
I looked at the legal pad one more time.
Then I slid it back to him and picked up my coffee.
"Call the mediator today," I said.
"Before school pickup."
He wrote something on the pad.
His hand was steady but his jaw wasn't.
"Okay," he said.
From upstairs, Daniel had begun to make the small preliminary sounds that meant he was waking up.
Not crying yet — just announcing himself, the way he was apparently going to do from now on.
Tom looked at the ceiling.
"I'll go," he said.
"I've got him."
I went upstairs.
Daniel was on his back with his fists raised, face beginning to scrunch into the expression that preceded the real noise.
I picked him up, held him upright against my shoulder, felt him immediately settle.
"Good morning," I said quietly.
He turned his head against my neck the way newborns do — instinctive, searching.
I stood at the window with him while the street outside woke up.
A neighbor walking a dog.
The first school-run cars.
The ordinary machinery of the day beginning its usual work, indifferent to everything that had shifted in this house over the past week.
My phone buzzed on the dresser.
It was Rachel.
Not a call.
A text.
*How did he sleep?*
I looked at the message for a moment.
Then I typed back: *Well.
He's already awake and very opinionated about it.*
Three dots appeared.
Then: *That's new.
He was so quiet in the hospital.*
I almost smiled.
*He's finding his voice.*
A longer pause.
Then: *Thank you for the photo.
I've looked at it a hundred times.*
I looked down at Daniel.
At the particular angle of his ears, which Sophie had correctly identified as Tom's.
At the shape of his mouth, which was not Tom's, which belonged to a woman I had never met who was beginning her second round of treatment and sending me updates about her son's sleep habits from a hospital room.
*I'll send another one today*, I typed.
*You don't have to.*
*I know*, I sent back.
*I want to.*
I took a photo of him in the morning light from the window — his eyes open now, unfocused, blinking at the brightness.
Then I sent it.
Rachel's reply came quickly this time.
*He looks so much better than he did.
He looked so small.*
*He is small*, I wrote.
*But he's loud.*
A longer pause.
Then: *I'm glad he has sisters.*
I stood there with the phone in one hand and Daniel against my shoulder, and I thought about what it meant to be glad about something you would never be part of.
About choosing to love someone enough to be happy for them from a distance.
About how much harder that was than anything she had asked of me.
*They already love him*, I typed.
*Especially the oldest.*
*Good*, she wrote.
And then: *That's everything.*
I put the phone in my pocket.
Downstairs, I could hear Tom on the phone — calling the mediator, I realized, an hour earlier than I'd asked.
His voice was low and careful and I could not make out the words, only the tone of a man who understood he was making the most important phone call of his life.
I looked at Daniel.
May you like
"You have no idea," I told him, "how complicated you are."
He yawned enormously, showing his gums, entirely unbothered.