The Anniversary Menu

I set the folder in the middle of the table, between the chicken and the candles.
“You said you pay for this house,” I told Nick. “Let’s talk about what you pay for.”
I opened the folder and laid out the first page.
“March third. A jeweler in Oak Brook. One Cartier bracelet. Seven thousand four hundred dollars.”
I looked at my left wrist.
“Not for me. I’ve worn the same plain band for two years.”
Nick’s jaw tightened.
Second page.
“April nineteenth. A leather goods boutique on Michigan Avenue. Fourteen thousand two hundred dollars.”
Jean went still.
“That was Jean’s birthday,” I said. “Nick told you it was a bonus gift, didn’t he?”
Her fingers slid to the Birkin beside her chair.
“It was a gift from my son,” she said, but her voice had thinned.
“It was a gift from my account.”
Third page.
“A watch dealer in Chicago. Nine thousand eight hundred dollars.”
Every eye drifted to Nick’s wrist, to the gold Rolex that caught the candlelight.
“The one the company gave you for hitting quota,” I said.
He pulled his sleeve down.
Fourth page.
“A rental office in Elmhurst. Twenty-one hundred and fifty dollars a month, for fourteen months.”
I let that number hang there.
“Thirty thousand, one hundred dollars for a one-bedroom apartment where my husband had his client dinners.”
My father’s chair creaked.
“Add it up,” I said. “Sixty-one thousand, five hundred dollars.”
“That’s our money!” Nick said. His voice cracked. “It’s a joint account. I earned it.”
“Every month, on the first, six thousand dollars arrives in that account,” I said. “You always thought it came from my little bookkeeping jobs. You never asked to see one invoice.”
His mouth opened.
“Where do you think it came from, Nick?”
He didn’t answer.
He looked at my father instead.
And my father looked back, calm as a lake in winter.
Nick laughed.
It was a thin, ugly laugh.
“Oh, I get it. Mel from the box factory is going to bail you out. Your dad’s cute little family business.” He turned to the table. “Fine. Divorce me. Illinois is an equitable state. I’ll take half of this house and see you in court.”
“Which house?” I asked.
I pulled out two more papers.
“This is the deed to 418 Prairie Street. Paid in full, in cash, two years ago. The owner is Elizabeth Chandler Barlow. Only her.”
Nick stared at it.
“Your dad co-signed—”
“My father bought it as a wedding gift. You signed an acknowledgment at closing. You never read it. You said you trusted me.”
I slid the second paper beside it.
“And this is the marital agreement you signed the day before our wedding in Ms. Gresham’s office.”
“I never—”
“You initialed every page,” I said. “Page four, paragraph nine. If either spouse is unfaithful, he waives any claim to property titled to the other.”
The room seemed to shrink.
“I handed you a pen, Nick. You didn’t even look up.”
Jean made a strangled noise.
“Dominick, tell me you didn’t sign something like that.”
“Mom, I—”
“Chandler,” Jean said suddenly, slowly, as if the word were tasting strange. “Your father’s name is Chandler.”
“Yes.”
“What does your father actually do?”
It was the first time in two years she’d asked.
My father pushed back his chair and stood again.
Not fast.
Not loud.
He wiped his hands on his flannel as if there were still flour on them from the kitchen.
“Melvin Chandler,” he said. “Nice to finally be asked.”
He turned to my husband.
“I run a little holding company out of Racine. Granite Point Holdings.”
Nick’s face changed.
I watched the color drain out of it, line by line.
“Granite Point,” he whispered.
“Six companies,” my father said. “One of them is Bluestem Packaging Group.”
“That’s... that’s my—”
“Your employer,” Dad said. “I’ve owned it for nineteen years.”
Norm slowly set down his wine.
Florence reached for my hand under the table.
Nick’s lips moved without sound.
“The Granite Point people,” he finally managed. “The ones in Racine who sign off on my budget.”
“That’s me.”
“You made regional director in April,” Dad went on. “I’d like you to know that wasn’t a favor. The board promoted you on your numbers. Your numbers were good. I was proud.”
Nick’s shoulders sagged a half inch.
“It’s the dinners I’m not proud of.”
“Thirty-one client dinners,” my father said. “Thirty-one expense reports filed to Bluestem. Our compliance department flagged them Friday afternoon. Two of the clients don’t exist. Eleven of the restaurants had no record of your reservations. Four hotel bar tabs were billed on the same evenings your joint card shows you at an apartment in Elmhurst.”
Silence.
“We call that fr*ud, Nick.”
“Mr. Chandler, sir, I can explain—”
“You have a meeting with legal at eight tomorrow morning. I’d bring a lawyer.” Dad’s voice was kind, which made it worse. “I didn’t touch that audit. I didn’t ask anyone to look at you. My daughter never asked me to.”
I met Nick’s eyes.
“I didn’t need to,” I said. “You did it yourself.”
He swayed.
For a moment I thought he might actually fall.
Then something on the tablecloth began to buzz.
His phone.
Face down, next to his water glass.
It rattled against the wood once, twice, three times.
Nick lunged.
Norm was faster.
His big, tired hand closed over the phone, and he turned it over.
The lock screen glowed in the candlelight.
May you like
Norm put on his reading glasses.
Then, in a voice I’d never heard from him, he read it out loud.