Chapter 5: The Question That Broke Me

Naomi spread the court papers across the hotel table.
“Richard filed this yesterday morning, before the wedding.”
Valerie stared at the date.
“He expected me to appear?”
“He knew you had booked a flight through JFK,” Naomi said.
“The petition quotes your itinerary.”
I looked at Valerie.
“How could he know that?”
“Your father’s assistant called my school last week,” she said.
“She claimed she was updating emergency records.”
Chloe pulled out a chair.
“Richard planned to use the order if Valerie came near us.”
“And now he’ll say I ruined his honeymoon,” Valerie replied.
“Our honeymoon was already a lie.”
Valerie’s eyes moved to Chloe’s bare hand.
“That doesn’t make you innocent.”
“No.” Chloe placed her room key on the table.
“But my family’s legal team is downstairs.
I asked them to work for you, not Richard.”
“Why would you do that?”
“Because I watched Richard turn my silence into a w*apon.
He doesn’t get to use it twice.”
Lucy wandered over with a sheet of paper.
Three figures stood beneath a purple sun.
“This is Mommy,” she said.
“This is me.
This one is Cloud.”
I crouched beside her.
“That’s a very good rabbit.”
She tilted her head.
“Did you get my letters?”
The room stopped.
“What did you say, sweetheart?” Valerie asked.
Lucy pointed to me.
“Mommy put my hand on them.
She said, ‘This one is for your daddy.’”
My knees touched the carpet.
“I didn’t get them,” I said.
“But I should have come looking long before you had to send one.”
“Why didn’t you?”
Valerie closed her eyes.
Chloe turned toward the window.
I tried to answer, but nothing came out.
Lucy placed Cloud in my lap.
“You can hold her if you’re sad.”
My face folded before I could stop it.
I pressed the stuffed rabbit to my chest, and the tears came in front of all of them.
Valerie knelt across from me.
“Carter, look at me.”
“I left you alone.”
“Yes.”
“I believed him because believing him was easier than standing up to him.”
“Yes.”
“I don’t deserve to ask you to forgive me.”
“No, you don’t.” Her voice softened.
“But Lucy deserves the truth, even when it makes us look terrible.”
Chloe sat beside Lucy and offered her a crayon.
“Would Cloud like a blue hat?”
“Pink,” Lucy said firmly.
“Pink it is.”
Naomi’s phone chimed.
She read the message twice.
“The DNA laboratory expedited the test.”
I stood slowly.
“And?”
“Probability of paternity is greater than 99.99 percent.”
Valerie covered her mouth.
I reached toward her, then stopped before touching her.
“I’m sorry,” I said.
“She needed you,” Valerie whispered.
“I know.”
“No, you need to hear it.
She had a fever when she was six months old, and I sat beside her hospital crib alone.
She took her first step toward a photograph of you because I was foolish enough to keep one.
She needed you, and your father made sure you never knew.”
Her tears fell.
Chloe put an arm around Lucy while Naomi quietly turned away.
“I cannot repair those days,” I said.
“Tell me what I can do today.”
“Tell the truth in court.”
“I will.”
Naomi lifted the forged waiver.
“First, we prove you didn’t sign this.”
Chloe unlocked her phone.
“My father uses the same document-security company as Sterling Holdings.
Every executive printer leaves an invisible identification code.”
Naomi held the page beneath the lamp.
“Can they trace it?”
“They already did.” Chloe displayed an email.
“This document came from the private printer inside Richard’s home office.”
I stared at her.
“How did you get that so quickly?”
“Because this isn’t the first false document Richard asked someone to prepare.”
Valerie stepped closer.
“What other document?”
May you like
Chloe’s finger hovered over an audio file.
“One that certified Lucy did not exist.”