Chapter 5: What Catherine Hid

Ruth was waiting in the rear booth of an all-night diner.
Malcolm had told me she disappeared after stealing money from the family business.
She pushed a cup of coffee toward me.
“You look like Catherine did the night she decided to leave him.”
“My mother never tried to leave.”
“Malcolm told you that?”
I sat across from her.
Paige remained standing until Ruth pointed to the seat beside me.
“You should hear this too,” Ruth said.
“You know who I am?”
“I know Malcolm paid you.
I also know you returned every dollar.”
Paige’s hand tightened around her purse.
“How?”
“Catherine asked me to watch the account.”
I leaned forward.
“My mother knew Paige?”
“No.
Your mother knew Malcolm.”
Ruth placed a sealed envelope on the table.
My name was written across it in my mother’s hand.
“Why didn’t you give me this years ago?”
“Because Malcolm obtained a court order claiming I had taken company funds.
My lawyer told me any contact with you could be twisted against us both.”
“Did you take the money?”
Ruth slid a ledger across the table.
“I moved it into a protected account because Malcolm was emptying the company.
Every dollar is still there.”
Paige opened the ledger.
“These payments match transfers in the copy of the trust.”
“You saw the trust?” Ruth asked.
“Last summer.
Malcolm took it from me.”
Ruth touched the sealed envelope.
“This is the original codicil.
Catherine left Evan fifty-one percent of the company, the garage property, and the house.
Malcolm was only trustee until Evan turned thirty-five.”
“I turned thirty-five last year.”
“That is why Malcolm needed Paige close to you.
He needed signatures buried among tax papers and loan renewals.”
My breathing shortened.
Paige reached for me, but I moved away.
“You handed me those papers,” I said.
“I didn’t know what they were.”
“You told me they were routine.”
“Because Malcolm told me they were.”
Ruth looked directly at Paige.
“Did you ever see him sign Evan’s name?”
“No, but I saw a stamp in his desk.”
“A signature stamp?” I asked.
Paige nodded.
“He said you used it for supplier checks.”
I pressed both hands against the table.
“My wife brought me the papers.
My father stamped my name.
Which part of my marriage belongs to me?”
Paige’s face folded.
“The mornings you made tea before I woke up.
The night you sat beside my mother until sunrise.
Every time I reached for you because I loved you—that was mine.”
Ruth slid out of the booth and sat beside me.
“Your mother trusted the wrong man too,” she said.
“That did not make her foolish, and it does not make you weak.”
I covered my face.
Ruth’s arm settled across my shoulders while Paige cried silently across the table.
“Where is the signature stamp now?” Ruth asked.
“In Malcolm’s garage,” Paige said.
“Bottom drawer beneath the old baseball glove.”
We entered through the side door just before dawn.
I lifted the glove from its hook while Paige pulled open the drawer.
“This?” she asked.
The stamp carried my name.
Ruth photographed it beside the forged mortgage papers.
A light clicked on behind us.
Malcolm stood in the doorway with the brown envelope in one hand.
“You never could stay out of my business, Ruth.”
“It was Catherine’s business,” she said.
Malcolm reached for the codicil, but Ruth held it behind her.
“Give me that.”
“No.”
He turned to me.
“She stole from your mother.
She’ll steal from you.”
Ruth raised her phone.
“Keep talking, Malcolm.
This is streaming to my attorney.”
His hand stopped in midair.
Paige reached beneath the workbench and pulled free a small black recorder held there with tape.
Malcolm’s face drained of color.
Paige pressed PLAY.
His voice filled the garage.
Once Evan signs away the house, nothing Catherine left him can be traced back to me.
Then another voice came through the recorder—a voice none of us expected.
“I’ll make certain the board removes him Monday,” the man said.
May you like
I recognized it immediately.
It belonged to the company attorney, Gerald Voss.