Chapter 10: Two Mothers

The DNA results came back on a Thursday morning.
I already knew what they would say.
I think I had known since the night I looked at the hospital photograph and saw the mark.
But knowing and having the paper in front of you are two different things.
The results said she was not my biological child.
I read the sentence three times.
Then I set the paper on the kitchen table and sat very still.
Liam came in from the hallway.
He read my face before he read the page.
"Rachel—"
"Get Dana," I said.
"And then call the solicitor."
The solicitor — a woman named Patricia Hale who Dana had found and who had agreed to see us the same day — was clear and direct and did not soften anything unnecessarily.
"If what the nurse has told you is accurate," Patricia said, "and if the DNA results are what you say, then you're looking at a situation involving at minimum a wrongful removal and obstruction.
If the grandmother acted deliberately and with the assistance of anyone inside the hospital, the criminal exposure is significant."
"We want our daughter," I said.
"That's the first thing."
"I understand.
And the law is on your side — the biological family of the child currently in your care will have equivalent standing, which means the other mother will also be seeking a return of her child.
These situations, when they proceed correctly, result in a reunification.
Both children go back to their biological families."
"She's been with us for two weeks," Liam said.
"I know," Patricia said.
"That doesn't change the biology.
It does affect how the reunification is handled — the court will want to ensure both children's welfare throughout the process.
But the endpoint is clear."
I thought about the baby upstairs.
About Noah, who had held her at the hospital and known.
About the stuffed rabbit he'd chosen from forty of them and would not be moved on.
"We need to find the other mother," I said.
Patricia nodded.
"We're working on that.
I've submitted a data request to the hospital under the legal framework and I expect we'll have her contact details by end of day." She paused.
"One more thing.
Carol Trent."
"What about her?"
"If she acted as described — accessing the ward under false credentials, interfering with the placement of two newborns — that is a serious crjminal matter.
The hospital will be under pressure to manage their own exposure, which means they may try to contain the narrative.
I'd encourage you not to speak to anyone from St.
Anne's without me present from this point forward."
"Ms.
Vickers already knows the DNA result is coming," I said.
"She'll know what it means."
"Then we move today.
Not tomorrow."
The other mother's name was Claire Marsh.
Patricia had it by two o'clock.
I called her myself.
I had asked Patricia if that was wise and Patricia had said: *you're the best person to make that call.
You're both mothers.
Start there.*
She answered on the third ring.
She sounded exhausted in the way that every new mother sounds exhausted — that specific depth of tired that is physical and emotional all at once.
"Claire," I said.
"My name is Rachel Calloway.
I had a baby at St.
Anne's on the same night as you."
A pause.
"I know why you're calling," she said.
My breath caught.
"You know?"
"My sister said I was crazy." Her voice was very quiet.
"But I've been saying it since the first night.
Something was wrong.
She didn't feel like mine.
I couldn't explain it.
I just—" She stopped.
"I didn't hold her at the hospital.
They took her away too quickly and when they brought her back I thought — I told myself I was just tired."
"Did she have a birthmark?" I asked.
"On her left wrist?"
Silence.
Then: "No.
She didn't.
But she was supposed to.
I saw her first.
For about thirty seconds in the delivery room.
She had a small dark mark on her left wrist and I remember thinking how sweet it was.
And then they took her and when they brought her back—"
She stopped.
"Rachel," she said.
"Are your DNA results back?"
"Yes."
A very long pause.
"So are mine," she said.
We cried.
Both of us, on the phone, two strangers who were also the closest thing to each other that existed in that moment.
May you like
We cried and then we talked for forty minutes and by the end of it we had agreed on one thing above everything else:
Whatever happened next, we would do it together.