Spotlight

Chapter 5: What Sutton Did Not Know She Had Already Lost

Sutton called twice the following morning before I had left Merritt's room.

I forwarded both missed calls to Vaughn and blocked her number from my personal phone.

She switched to email by noon.

The email was three paragraphs long.

The first paragraph expressed concern for Merritt.

The second explained that the device malfunction had been an accident — that she had only been trying to adjust a strap that appeared to be irritating Merritt's skin.

The third paragraph noted that she was certain this entire situation could be resolved without involving the legal system, and that she hoped I would think carefully about the damage a public dispute could cause Merritt's emotional wellbeing.

Merritt's emotional wellbeing.

I forwarded the email to Vaughn without comment.

He called ten minutes later.

"She's trying to build a negligence defense," he said.

"Accidental adjustment of a strap.

It won't hold against Petra's photos, but she doesn't know about Petra yet."

"Should we tell her?"

"Absolutely not.

Let her build the defense.

Every word she puts in writing is a gift."

That afternoon, Thatcher arrived at the hospital.

I was in the hallway outside Merritt's room when he stepped out of the elevator.

He was wearing the grey jacket he always wore when he wanted to look responsible.

He stopped when he saw me.

"Winslow."

"She's resting," I said.

"You can go in.

But I'm going to stay."

He nodded slowly.

Something in his posture had changed since the driveway.

The recording confidence was gone.

He looked older, and not in a dignified way.

He went in.

I stood in the doorway.

Merritt opened her eyes when she heard him.

She didn't reach for the writing board immediately.

She just looked at him.

"Hey, sweetheart," Thatcher said.

His voice broke slightly on the last word.

Merritt picked up the board.

She wrote: *Why didn't you stop her?*

Thatcher sat down in the chair beside the bed.

He clasped his hands together and looked at them.

"I don't have a good answer for that," he said quietly.

She turned the board over.

She didn't write anything else.

She turned toward the window.

Thatcher sat there for another twenty minutes without speaking.

Then he stood, kissed the top of her head very gently, and walked back into the hallway.

He didn't look at me until he reached the elevator.

"I know what's coming," he said.

"Then you understand why."

The elevator opened.

He stepped in.

"I'm not going to fight it," he said.

The doors closed.

I stood in the hallway a moment longer.

Then I went back in and sat beside Merritt.

She had the board again.

She wrote: *Is it going to be okay?*

"Yes," I said.

She wrote: *For real or just saying it?*

I took her hand.

"For real," I said.

She looked at me for a long moment.

Then she set the board down and leaned her head back against the pillow.

That evening, Vaughn called with news I had not anticipated.

"The DA's office has been in contact," he said.

"They're moving faster than I expected.

Apparently Petra's company filed their insurance documentation this morning and it flagged a regulatory review.

That elevated the case automatically."

"What does that mean?"

"It means the DA doesn't need to wait for us to formally push.

The regulatory flag triggers their own inquiry.

Sutton is going to receive a notice as early as tomorrow."

I sat down in the corridor chair.

"She won't know where it came from," Vaughn continued.

"As far as she knows, she's still negotiating with you privately."

"She sent another email this afternoon," I said.

"Asking me to call her."

"Did you respond?"

"No."

"Good.

Let her wait.

The notice is going to hit her before she expects anything.

And Winslow — I need you to be ready for her to escalate when it does.

She's going to look for whoever she thinks gave her up."

"Hayes."

"Almost certainly.

He's the one who made the call to you.

She knows that."

I thought about Hayes standing in that driveway, stepping back first, saying *I'm out.* And then quietly giving Petra Langley my phone number.

"Can we do anything to protect him?"

"I've already spoken with him.

He's prepared to make a formal statement.

He's not going to walk it back." A pause.

"He said to tell you that he should have called you months ago."

I didn't respond to that for a moment.

"Tell him I'm glad he called when he did," I said finally.

After I hung up, I sat in the quiet hallway with the sound of the hospital around me and thought about Sutton somewhere across the city, composing careful emails, convinced she was still controlling the story.

She had no idea the regulatory notice was already printed.

She had no idea Petra existed.

She had no idea that the cloud account she had never once thought about was the reason everything she said next would only make things worse.

The next morning, Vaughn's assistant forwarded me a single document.

May you like

The DA's office had opened a formal investigation.

Named subject: Sutton Aldridge.

Related Stories

Other posts