Chapter 4: Forty-Eight Thousand Lies

I picked up the deposit slip.
Alice’s name appeared beside an account number, and the date was three months before Clark left me.
“You had already opened an account together,” I said.
Clark lowered his voice.
“It wasn’t what you think.”
“You were sleeping beside me while putting my mother’s money into Alice’s account.
What am I supposed to think?”
Alice folded her arms.
“That Clark was protecting an investment.”
“What investment?”
“My fitness studio.”
The room seemed to tilt.
Olivia took the paper from my shaking hand and read it twice.
“Grandma gave Dad money to save Mom’s business,” she said.
“You used it to open a studio for yourself?”
“It was a short-term loan,” Alice replied.
“The studio was going to repay everything.”
“Did it?”
Alice’s smile returned.
“Business plans change.”
I turned to Clark.
“When I begged you for help, you said there was nothing left.”
“I was going to replace it.”
“When?”
“Mara—”
“Before or after my mother was gone?”
Clark flinched.
Alice stepped between us.
“Be careful.
You signed a divorce settlement confirming that all financial matters had been disclosed.”
“I signed what my attorney gave me.”
“Exactly.” Alice unlocked her phone and held up a photograph.
“Page fourteen.
You released Clark from any future financial claim.”
Daniel leaned closer.
“That document doesn’t make someone else’s loan disappear.”
Alice glanced at him.
“You sell jewelry.
You don’t practice law.”
Olivia placed the designer dress back into its box.
“We don’t want this.”
Alice pushed it toward her.
“Keep it.
You may need something respectable after your mother spends everything she has on attorneys.”
“Stop talking to her like that,” I said.
“Or what?” Alice asked.
“You’ll sue us on a cashier’s paycheck?”
The words struck harder because she knew exactly how thin my bank account was.
Clark stared at the floor.
“Tell her,” Alice ordered him.
“Tell Mara she cannot prove where that money went after it entered our account.”
“Our account?” I asked.
Clark finally looked at her.
“You said it was yours.”
“It became joint after we moved in together.”
Daniel slipped the papers back into his envelope.
“My copy proves the deposit.”
“It proves a deposit,” Alice said.
“Not ownership.”
Olivia held up her phone.
“The receipt proves you had Grandma’s bracelet.”
“And your mother can’t say how I got it.”
My fingers tightened around the chair.
Alice walked close enough for me to smell her perfume.
“You have a sad story, Mara.
That doesn’t make it evidence.”
“You took something from my mother.”
“Prove it.”
Olivia stepped between us.
“I found the bracelet in your drawer.
I photographed the papers beside it.”
Alice’s face changed.
“What papers?”
“The bank statements under your jewelry tray.”
“You photographed private records?”
“I photographed Grandma’s check.”
Alice grabbed Olivia’s wrist.
“Give me that phone.”
“Let her go,” I said.
Clark caught Alice’s arm, and she released Olivia.
Then Alice dialed a number.
“Yes,” she said when someone answered.
“I need an officer sent to this address.
A girl entered my bedroom and took jewelry, financial records, and a designer dress.”
“You gave me the dress,” Olivia said.
“I did not.”
Clark stared at Alice.
“What are you doing?”
“Protecting us.”
“You’re accusing your own boyfriend’s daughter.”
Alice covered the phone.
“You can support me, Clark, or you can explain the forty-eight thousand dollars by yourself.”
A siren sounded somewhere down the street.
Olivia’s face lost its color.
May you like
Alice smiled at me.
“Let’s see how brave your daughter feels when the police ask who really stole from whom.”