Chapter 6: The Woman Before Sarah

Marcus slid his phone across the table.
On the screen was a photograph — a wedding announcement, the kind that used to run in small-town newspapers.
A couple smiling outside a church.
The man was in his mid-forties, pleasant-faced, ordinary-looking.
The woman beside him was wearing a different hairstyle and a different name beneath the photo.
But I recognized the face.
"Her name in that photograph is Vanessa Colton," Marcus said.
"That was seven years ago, in a town called Millhaven, Ohio.
The man's name was Robert Deering.
He owned a small manufacturing company.
Comfortable, not wealthy.
But he had a property trust set up by his father and a life insurance policy worth two hundred and eighty thousand dollars."
I put the phone down.
"What happened to him?"
"He's alive.
He lives in Millhaven.
He never remarried." Marcus took the phone back.
"The marriage lasted fourteen months.
It ended when Robert's adult daughter from a previous relationship hired a financial consultant to review the family estate.
The consultant found irregularities.
Robert confronted Vanessa.
She left before any charges were filed."
"She walked away clean."
"She walked away with sixty thousand dollars from a joint account and a car registered in both names.
His daughter tried to pursue it.
The attorney said the joint account withdrawal was legal.
The car was a gray area." Marcus shrugged.
"Vanessa was careful.
She always stays just inside the line until she's ready to cross it."
"And then she crosses it."
"And then she crosses it." He looked at me.
"You were further along than Robert.
The property value was higher, the relationship was more established, and she had more time to construct the paperwork.
If tonight hadn't happened exactly the way it did—"
He stopped.
"If Lily hadn't found that key," I said.
He didn't answer.
He didn't need to.
I thought about Lily hiding behind the painting during the venue walkthrough.
Finding the key.
Saying nothing to me because she wasn't sure I'd believe her.
Carrying it for two days.
Watching Vanessa across the dinner table and keeping that small brass key tucked somewhere safe, waiting.
My eight-year-old daughter had done what I should have done months ago.
"I need to speak to Robert Deering," I said.
"I thought you might.
I have his number." Marcus pulled out a card and wrote it on the back.
"He agreed to be contacted.
He said — and I'm quoting — 'Tell him I'm sorry I didn't warn more people.'"
I set the card on the table.
I looked at it for a moment.
"Vanessa knew about Sarah's custody situation before I did," I said.
"She knew things about our divorce that were private.
How?"
Marcus leaned back.
"That's the piece I'm still working on.
Someone gave her access to information she shouldn't have had.
A family friend, a mutual acquaintance, someone with access to legal records." He met my eyes.
"Or someone closer than that."
I thought about that.
And then I thought about the one person who had been present throughout my divorce, who had managed the paperwork, who had known every financial detail of my father's estate.
My attorney.
Not Paul.
Paul was past retirement age and had been appalled tonight.
His junior partner.
The one who had actually handled the day-to-day filing.
"Marcus," I said slowly.
"What's the name of the notary on the forged trust document?"
He checked his notes.
May you like
He read me the name.
It was the same as Paul's junior partner.