Chapter 5: The Signature That Wasn’t Mine

Margaret shut off the recorder.
“That conversation did not happen the way it sounds.”
Claire stared at her.
“How else can it sound?”
“I believed Rachel was voluntarily placing you in temporary care.”
“Did you see her sign anything?” I asked.
Margaret picked up her folder.
“I will not discuss a former client’s confidential matter.”
David stepped beside her.
“You heard her.
This is over.”
Emily blocked the office door.
“You threatened Mom’s sister with my safety.”
David pointed at the recorder.
“That file is eighteen years old.
It has been edited.”
Claire’s voice trembled.
“My mother was crying.”
“Rachel cried whenever she wanted sympathy.”
My palm struck the desk.
“Do not speak about my sister that way.”
David leaned closer.
“Your sister lied to you.
She stole from us, disappeared, and left you to clean up the shame.”
“No,” Claire said.
“You left me in foster care.”
“She signed you away.”
David opened Margaret’s folder and removed a document.
“Here is the surrender agreement.
Rachel’s signature is at the bottom.”
Claire read it.
Her face crumpled.
“She didn’t want me.”
Emily put both arms around her.
“That’s what he wants you to believe.”
“The paper says it.”
I reached for Claire, but she stepped away.
“You searched for Rachel,” she said to me.
“Did you ever search for a child?”
“I didn’t know you existed.”
“You saw my photograph last night.
For one second, you looked at me like I had stolen your sister’s face.”
Her words folded me in half.
I gripped the edge of the desk.
“I’m sorry,” I whispered.
“For one terrible second, I blamed you for bringing all of this into my home.”
Claire’s eyes filled.
“And I spent my whole life believing no one wanted me.”
Emily pulled us together.
Claire resisted, then pressed her face against my shoulder.
“I would have wanted you,” I said.
“If I had known, I would have come.”
David gave a bitter laugh.
“A touching performance won’t change a legal document.”
Mrs.
Alvarez picked up the surrender agreement.
“There are two witness signatures.”
Margaret looked down.
“One is mine.”
Mrs.
Alvarez pointed to the second.
“And this one says Anna Ellis.”
I took the page.
The letters looked like my handwriting, but the final stroke curled the wrong way.
“I never signed this.”
David’s face remained still.
“You sign papers without reading them all the time.”
“Not eighteen years ago.
I signed Morgan then.
I didn’t take your name until our tenth anniversary.”
Margaret snatched the document.
“That cannot be right.”
Emily took a photograph of it.
David moved toward her.
“Delete that.”
“No.”
“I pay your tuition.
I pay for your apartment.
If you keep doing this, you will lose everything.”
Emily held Claire’s hand.
“Then take it.”
David looked at me.
“Anna, bring your daughter home and we can still fix this.”
“She is standing exactly where she belongs.”
Margaret flipped through the folder with shaking fingers.
A small card fell onto the floor.
Claire picked it up.
It was a receipt from St.
Catherine’s Residential Center, dated six months earlier.
The resident’s name was Rebecca Moore.
On the back, someone had written:
Rachel Morgan — mail returned by David Ellis.
Claire looked at Margaret.
“You said my mother signed me away eighteen years ago.
Why was David returning her mail six months ago?”
Margaret opened her mouth, but no words came.
Her phone rang.
She glanced at the number and answered.
A woman shouted loudly enough for all of us to hear.
May you like
“Margaret, don’t let David leave.
Rachel is asking for Anna.”