Spotlight

Chapter 3: What Howard's Lawyer Said

The phone rang four times before a woman's voice answered.

"Hartwell Estate Law, this is Carol."

"Carol, this is Evelyn Mercer.

I need to speak with Richard Hartwell tonight.

I understand it's Christmas.

I also understand that someone has been accessing documents that belong to me, and I need to know what has been filed and what has not."

A short silence.

Then: "Mrs.

Mercer, Mr.

Hartwell left instructions that if you ever called after hours, we were to put you through immediately."

I gripped the phone a little tighter.

"He did?"

"Yes, ma'am.

One moment."

Daniel had not moved from the doorway.

Melissa had come to stand beside him.

They were watching me the way people watch a situation that has gone further than they planned.

Richard Hartwell picked up on the second ring.

His voice was steady and warm, the same voice I remembered from Howard's funeral.

"Evelyn.

I've been waiting for this call."

"Then you know why I'm calling."

"I have a good idea.

Tell me what they've said to you."

I turned slightly away from the doorway so I could think clearly.

"Daniel told me there's a letter.

A document Howard left with you.

He said it transfers ownership of the house to them if I move out."

A pause.

Long enough that my chest tightened.

"Evelyn, there is a letter.

Howard did leave one with me.

But I need you to listen carefully, because what Daniel told you is not what that letter says."

My hand found the edge of Howard's desk.

"Then what does it say?"

"It says the opposite.

Howard was very specific.

The house belongs to you outright, permanently, with no conditions attached.

He was concerned — and he expressed this to me directly — that someone might one day try to convince you otherwise.

He asked me to keep a notarized copy for exactly that reason."

I turned back to face the doorway.

Daniel's jaw had gone tight.

Melissa's hand had dropped from his arm.

"Richard," I said, "has anyone contacted your office in the past year?

Anyone attempting to access Howard's estate file or request copies of documents?"

Another pause.

This one felt careful.

"Yes.

Approximately eight months ago, someone called claiming to be your authorized representative.

They asked for a full copy of Howard's estate documents.

Carol flagged it because they couldn't produce a valid authorization code.

We declined the request and logged it."

Eight months ago.

One month after Daniel and Melissa moved in.

"Who made that call?" I asked.

"The caller gave the name Melissa Mercer," Richard said.

"She claimed you had given her permission."

I did not look away from my daughter-in-law's face when I said, "I gave her no such permission."

Melissa's expression didn't break.

But her chin lifted — just slightly — in the way it always did when she was recalculating.

"Evelyn," Richard said, "I want you to come into the office the day after Christmas.

Bring nothing and no one except yourself.

I'll have everything laid out for you.

The original documents, the flagged call log, and something else Howard asked me to hold until I judged the timing to be right."

"Something else?"

"A second letter," he said.

"One he wrote for you alone.

He told me — and these are his words — that you would know when you needed to read it."

My throat closed.

"I'll be there at nine," I said.

"I'll be waiting."

I ended the call and set the phone face-down on Howard's desk.

The room was very quiet.

Outside in the dining room, someone laughed at something, and silverware clinked against china — my china — and for a moment the distance between that sound and where I was standing felt enormous.

Daniel spoke first.

"Mom—"

"Not tonight," I said.

"You need to let us explain—"

"I said not tonight." I picked up my phone and slipped it into my pocket.

"You should go back to your guests.

That is, after all, what this evening was for."

I walked out of the study, down the hall, and up the stairs.

I did not look back.

Behind me, I heard Melissa's voice — low and tight and meant only for Daniel.

"She doesn't have the key," she said.

"She can't get into the drawer."

I stopped on the third step.

I had not told either of them that the drawer key was missing from my keychain.

May you like

I had only said the drawer was locked.

The only way Melissa knew about the key was if she had already taken it.

Related Stories

Other posts