Chapter 4: What Dean Found

I didn't ask Dean to explain immediately.
Something in his expression told me to wait.
He came back to the living room, pulled the ottoman away from the armchair Priscilla was sitting in, and sat down directly across from her.
He leaned forward with his elbows on his knees, the way he used to sit as a boy when he was working through a problem he didn't know how to solve.
"I've been tracking something for three weeks," he said.
"I didn't tell either of you because I wasn't certain."
Priscilla went very still.
"After Marcus came to dinner in October — you remember, Mom, you invited him because you felt sorry about how the August visit ended—"
"I remember," I said.
"After that dinner, I noticed something.
My own account had a small unfamiliar charge.
Just forty-two dollars.
I assumed it was a subscription.
But then another one appeared two weeks later.
Different vendor.
Similar amount." He paused.
"I started looking more carefully."
"Dean." Priscilla's voice had changed.
"What are you saying?"
"I'm saying Marcus didn't only have Mom's card number." He looked at her steadily.
"Priscilla, how did Marcus get my debit card information?"
The color left her face completely.
"I never gave him your—"
"My wallet was in my coat pocket at that October dinner.
I hung my coat in the front hallway.
Marcus arrived early and offered to hang the other coats when guests came in." Dean kept his voice perfectly even.
"I checked the security footage from the hallway camera I installed last spring.
The one you said was unnecessary."
Priscilla's mouth opened.
Nothing came out.
"He was in that hallway for four minutes with the coats.
Alone." Dean picked up his phone and turned it toward her.
A paused security video.
A figure in the hallway, coat open, reaching inside.
"That's your cousin at my mother's dinner.
Going through my wallet."
I looked at the still image on the screen.
The hallway.
The coats.
A figure with his back to the camera, but the dark green jacket was familiar.
I had complimented Marcus on that jacket at dinner.
"He photographed the cards," Dean said.
"Both of them.
And then he put everything back."
Priscilla stood up from the armchair.
"I didn't know.
Dean, I swear I didn't know he would do that."
"I know you didn't plan it with him," Dean said.
"But you opened the door.
When you gave him Mom's number in August, you told him this family was an easy target."
She flinched.
It was a small movement, but I saw it.
"What did the call just now tell you?" I asked Dean.
"I called a fraud investigator I know from work.
I sent him screenshots of both accounts.
He said the pattern across both cards, the amounts, the vendor types, the timing — it's a structured approach.
Small enough charges to avoid automatic flags.
Spread out over months.
He's seen it before." Dean set his phone on the coffee table.
"Marcus has done this to other people."
The room was quiet.
"How much?" I asked.
Dean hesitated for just a moment.
"Across both cards, going back to August — he estimates at least three thousand.
Possibly more if there are charges we haven't found yet."
Three thousand dollars.
I thought about the water heater I had helped pay for.
The birthday dinners.
The vacation deposits.
I thought about every time I had told myself that being generous was the same as being loved.
"I want to cancel the card," I said.
"Not yet." Dean picked up his phone again.
"If we cancel it now, Marcus knows we've found him and he disappears.
My contact says to leave it active for forty-eight hours while the report is being filed.
Let him think it's still working."
Priscilla sat back down.
She was hugging her own arms.
"Are you going to call the police?"
"My contact will coordinate with them," Dean said.
"This isn't a one-family matter anymore."
She looked up at him.
"And us?
What happens to us?"
Dean didn't answer immediately.
He picked up his gloves from where they had fallen on the rug, folded them together carefully, and set them on the side table.
"We'll talk about us after Mom is protected," he said.
Priscilla looked at me.
I held her gaze for a moment, then looked away.
I didn't have anything to offer her right then.
The Christmas music was still off.
The invoice from the caterer was still sitting beside my teacup.
And somewhere out there, Marcus Hale was probably spending my money on dinner or petrol or whatever came next on his quiet, careful list.
My phone buzzed on the side table.
I turned it over.
An unknown number.
A text message.
May you like
Four words.
*Merry Christmas, Aunt Patricia.*