Spotlight

Chapter 10: What the Solicitor Found

Arthur called at eight forty-five the following morning.

I was already dressed.

I had slept, properly, for the first time in weeks.

"Mrs.

Hollis," he said.

"I've heard from Robert Hollis's solicitor."

"And?"

"The letters he mentioned — the alleged correspondence from Thomas — his solicitor has agreed to share copies for review.

We should have them by Friday." A pause.

"I've also taken the liberty of contacting a colleague who specializes in undue influence claims.

Given the prepared transfer document and the coordinated approach, she believes there may be grounds to pursue this formally if you choose to."

"Do I need to decide that now?"

"No.

But I want you to know the option exists."

I looked out the kitchen window.

Daniel was in the garden, sitting on the bench near the apple tree, a mug of tea in both hands.

He had slept on the sofa.

I had found him there this morning, covered in the old plaid blanket from the sitting room.

"Arthur," I said.

"If those letters are genuine — if Thomas really did write something to Robert — does it change anything legally?"

"A letter expressing a general intention has no legal force," he said.

"It would need to be a formal agreement, witnessed and signed, to constitute a binding commitment.

A casual letter saying he hoped things might work out a certain way — that means nothing in law."

"And if the letters are not genuine?"

He was quiet for a moment.

"Then we have a different and more serious matter on our hands."

I hadn't allowed myself to think about that directly until now.

Thomas writing to Robert in the warm, hopeful language of brothers.

Thomas meaning no harm by it, not imagining it would be used this way.

Or Thomas writing nothing at all, and someone deciding the letters were necessary.

"Let's wait until Friday," I said.

"Of course." Another pause.

"Mrs.

Hollis — I want to say something, and I hope you'll take it in the spirit it's intended.

In thirty years of practice, I have seen a great many situations like this one.

Families.

Property.

People who believed that love made them entitled to something that was never theirs to take." His voice was measured and careful.

"You handled this with remarkable clarity.

Most people don't."

"I had a very good neighbor," I said.

Patricia, when I rang her afterward, said: "Oh, don't give me credit.

You knew something was wrong.

You paid attention.

That's all you."

"You made the appointment."

"You kept it," she said.

"Come over for lunch.

I want to hear everything."

I was at her door by noon.

We sat in her bright kitchen with soup and bread and the easy familiarity of thirty-one years of shared fence and borrowed sugar and the particular trust that only accumulates slowly, over time, in the small and unremarkable exchanges of ordinary life.

She listened to everything.

When I finished, she was quiet for a moment.

"What will you do about Daniel?" she asked.

"I don't know yet," I said honestly.

"He made choices I can't pretend didn't happen.

But he also stopped.

He sat at that table and chose me when it mattered.

That counts for something."

"And Vanessa?"

"She's still there," I said.

"She hasn't said she'll leave.

She hasn't said she won't.

She's waiting."

"For what?"

I wrapped both hands around my soup bowl.

"For the letters, I think.

She still believes Robert has something to use."

Patricia's eyes were steady and warm and very sensible.

"And if he doesn't?"

"Then she'll have nothing left to stand on," I said.

"And she'll know it."

The letters arrived by Friday, as promised.

Arthur called me at two in the afternoon, and I drove to his office.

He spread three photocopied pages on the desk.

I looked at them.

The handwriting was familiar — not perfectly, not immediately, but familiar in the way that all old family handwriting blurs together over time.

The kind of handwriting you could believe.

Arthur pointed to the signature at the bottom of the third page.

I leaned in and looked at it.

Then I looked at Arthur.

"Thomas always signed his full name," I said.

"His first name, middle initial, surname.

He did it every time.

He said his father had taught him that a man's name was worth knowing completely."

Arthur nodded.

He turned the third page slightly.

The signature at the bottom read: *Tom.*

"He never," I said, "in fifty-two years of marriage, signed anything Tom."

Arthur removed his reading glasses and placed them carefully on the desk.

May you like

"No," he said.

"I didn't think he had."

Related Stories

Other posts