Spotlight

Chapter 5: The Truth Marcus Hid

The bailiff caught Mr.

Pike before he reached the handle.

Pike twisted his arm away and dropped the phone beneath a bench.

“Get your hands off me.”

Judge Cole stood.

“Mr.

Pike, step away from the device.”

“I am the elected prosecutor.”

“And this is a preservation order.”

The security officer retrieved the phone.

Its screen had cracked, but the message remained visible.

Judge Whitcombe walked down from the bench.

“That phone contains privileged communications.”

Eleanor blocked his path with her cane.

“Then you can explain your privilege to the board.”

Whitcombe leaned close to her.

“You have no idea what the Brooks family is hiding.”

Isaiah heard him.

“Then say it out loud.”

The judge turned.

“Your brother lied about where he was that night.”

Marcus shut his eyes.

Isaiah looked at him.

“Is that true?”

“Not here.”

“Yes, here,” Whitcombe said.

“Your brother was two streets from the store.”

Isaiah’s fingers curled around the briefcase handle.

“Marcus?”

Marcus gripped the railing.

“I was working at Lawson’s loading dock.”

“Why didn’t you tell us?”

“Because they paid cash, and I knew Mom would ask why.”

“Why were you hiding money?”

Marcus looked directly at his younger brother.

“For you.”

Isaiah took a step back.

“You wanted that summer program in Washington.

Mom couldn’t afford it, and you stopped mentioning it.” Marcus’s voice cracked.

“I thought if I worked nights, I could put the money in Dad’s briefcase and pretend he’d saved it.”

Isaiah set the briefcase down as though it had become too heavy.

“You let them hold you for nine days to hide that?”

“No.

I stayed quiet because I saw who ran from the store.”

Whitcombe’s head snapped up.

Eleanor moved beside Marcus.

“Who did you see?”

“Caleb Whitcombe.”

The room went still.

Judge Cole looked at Harlan Whitcombe.

“Your grandson?”

Marcus nodded.

“He came through the alley in a gray jacket.

His left hand was wrapped in a towel.”

Whitcombe pointed at him.

“You expect this court to believe that now?”

“I told Mr.

Pike the first night.”

Every face turned toward the prosecutor.

Pike shook his head.

“He never mentioned Caleb.”

“You wrote it down,” Marcus said.

“Then you tore the page from your pad.”

Judge Cole ordered Marcus’s interview notes brought to the courtroom.

Pike smiled when the evidence officer returned with an empty evidence sleeve.

“No original notes,” the officer said.

“Only the final report.”

Pike spread his hands.

“There is your answer.”

Eleanor’s face hardened.

“Your office lost the notes?”

“There is no proof they existed.”

Judge Cole examined the documents.

“Without the original notes or a verified recording, Marcus’s claim cannot yet be confirmed.”

Whitcombe put his robe over one arm.

“And the hallway recording does not establish what was on that drive.

Marcus remains the identified suspect.”

For the first time that morning, the old confidence returned to his face.

Judge Cole looked at Eleanor.

“I can postpone the hearing for forty-eight hours, but I cannot dismiss the case on suspicion alone.”

Marcus was led toward the side door.

“Isaiah, take care of Mom.”

“No,” Isaiah said.

“I’m bringing you home.”

Whitcombe stopped beside him.

“You should have listened when I told you this wasn’t a mock trial.”

Isaiah lifted his eyes.

“And you should have listened when I said I made copies.”

The judge’s smile disappeared.

A woman in the last pew rose slowly.

She wore a grocery-store uniform and held an old phone against her chest.

“My name is Abigail Reed,” she said.

“I gave the original statement.”

Mr.

Pike stared at her.

“You were instructed not to come here.”

“I was also instructed to identify Marcus.”

May you like

She held up the phone.

“And I recorded the man who instructed me.”

Related Stories

Other posts