Spotlight

Chapter 10: The Deal Gary Made

Gary's attorney was a man named Philip Reece — expensive suit, careful manner, the kind of lawyer hired specifically to translate a client's panic into something manageable.

He and Patricia met without me present, which Patricia insisted on.

She said having me in the room would only give Gary's side something to play against.

She called me afterward.

"He's offering full cooperation," she said.

"In exchange for consideration on sentencing, he will provide a sworn statement detailing every aspect of the financial scheme — the original plan, how the transfers were structured, whose idea it was, how long it ran, and what was discussed in the days before Claire d*ed."

"What does 'consideration on sentencing' mean?"

"It means he's hoping to avoid prison or significantly reduce his time.

Whether the prosecutor accepts that is Karen Voss's decision, not mine.

But his offer of cooperation is significant, because it means he has information that he believes is worth something to them."

"Information about Vanessa."

"Almost certainly, yes." A pause.

"Nathan, when someone in a conspiracy offers to cooperate, it usually means they've calculated that the evidence against them is already strong enough that silence won't save them.

They're trying to trade what they know about the other person for a better outcome for themselves."

"So he's going to give her up."

"That appears to be the direction."

I sat with that.

I thought about Gary at Claire's funeral, his hand on my shoulder, his voice telling me she had been so careful with money.

I thought about him going through her files and telling me there was nothing important.

Six years of carrying that.

And now, faced with a formal inquiry, he had decided that Vanessa's survival was worth less than his own.

"Did he say anything about the night of the accident?" I asked.

Patricia was quiet for a moment.

"His attorney indicated that Gary has information relevant to the events of that evening.

He did not specify what."

"He was there," I said.

"Lily remembered a man parked across the street.

He was still there after Vanessa left."

"That will be part of the sworn statement, if he cooperates fully."

"And Vanessa?

Has she been notified about the inquiry?"

"Her attorney will have been contacted by now, yes."

I thought about Vanessa finding out that Gary was cooperating.

I thought about what she would do with that information.

"She's going to try something," I said.

"Probably," Patricia said.

"Which is why I want you to be careful.

And why I've already requested that any contact she makes — to you, to the children's school, to anyone in your immediate life — be documented immediately."

Two days after that call, Vanessa's attorney sent a letter to Patricia.

It contained an offer.

Vanessa would provide her own full cooperation with the inquiry, including a sworn account of the events of the night Claire d*ed, in exchange for immunity from the more serious potential charges.

She was offering to be the one who told the full story first.

Patricia called me the moment she received it.

"She found out Gary is cooperating," I said.

"Yes."

"She's trying to get ahead of him."

"Yes." Patricia's voice was measured.

"Karen Voss is now in a position where both subjects are offering to cooperate.

Which means the prosecutor's office will learn the full truth of that night — from at least one of them, probably both — because each of them is now racing to give information before the other one does."

The room around me felt very still.

"They're going to tell it," I said.

"One of them is going to say exactly what happened on that road."

"Yes," Patricia said.

"Nathan — prepare yourself.

Whatever comes next, the truth about that night is going to be spoken out loud.

In a formal setting.

On the record."

I looked at Claire's letter still on the kitchen table.

*Please look at the accounts.*

May you like

"Good," I said.

"It's time."

Related Stories

Other posts