Spotlight

Chapter 4: Detective Karen Holt

Her name was Karen Holt, and she arrived in thirty-seven minutes.

She was not what I expected.

No uniform, no badge on a lanyard.

She wore a gray blazer over a plain white shirt and carried a leather notebook under one arm.

She was somewhere in her mid-fifties, with short silver hair and the kind of eyes that didn't move around a room — they settled on one thing at a time and stayed there until they were finished.

She settled on me first.

"Lily." She pulled the chair from the corner and placed it directly across from the bed.

No desk between us.

No clipboard.

"I'm Karen.

Robert called me because he's worried about you.

I'd like to understand what's happening.

Can you tell me, in your own words, everything you remember about the night you lost your arms?"

"I don't remember it," I said.

"That's the problem."

"Tell me what you do remember.

Before that night.

The days leading up to it."

I thought back.

The memories from that period had always felt thin, like trying to read something through frosted glass.

I'd assumed it was the trauma.

I'd assumed it was the grief.

Daniel had always said the mind protects itself.

"We had an argument," I said slowly.

"A few days before.

I think.

It's hard to—" I stopped.

Something shifted in the edge of the memory.

"He wanted me to sign something.

I remember him putting papers in front of me and I said I wanted to read them first.

He got quiet.

The kind of quiet that felt wrong."

Karen's pen moved.

"Do you remember what the papers were?"

"No.

The next thing I clearly remember is waking up in that facility.

Without my arms."

Karen looked at Dr.

Robert.

Something passed between them that I couldn't read.

She looked back at me.

"Lily, I want to ask you about your finances.

Before the surgery.

Were you employed?"

"Yes.

I was a software developer.

I'd been with the same company for four years."

"Did you have savings?

Assets?"

"I had a trust fund." The words felt strange coming out, like I'd forgotten they were true.

"My grandmother left it to me when I was twenty-two.

It was substantial.

I was the sole beneficiary."

Karen's pen stopped moving.

"Does Daniel have access to that trust fund?"

The room got very quiet.

"He—" I had to think.

After I came home from the facility, Daniel had handled everything.

The accounts, the bills, the financial decisions.

He'd told me it was easier, that I shouldn't have to worry about numbers while I was healing.

"I signed things," I said.

"I signed a lot of things in that first year.

I don't remember all of them."

"Because of the sedation," Dr.

Robert said.

Karen looked at him once, then back at me.

"I'm going to need you to consent to a formal investigation.

That means giving me access to your financial records, your medical records, and your prescription history.

It also means that whatever happens in this room today does not go back to Daniel."

"He's outside," George said from the corner.

"He hasn't left."

Karen glanced at George for the first time since she'd walked in.

Something in her expression shifted slightly — a recognition, perhaps, of the kind of man George was.

The kind who showed up and stayed.

"Good," she said.

"I want him right where he is."

She turned a page in her notebook.

"Lily, I need to ask you something and I need you to think carefully.

In the three years since the surgery — has Daniel ever prevented you from speaking to family members?

Friends?

Anyone from your life before?"

I thought about my sister, Paula.

The way Daniel always answered the phone when she called in those first months.

The way he'd told me, gently, that Paula was finding it hard to see me like this, that maybe it was better to give her space.

The way Paula had stopped calling.

"My sister," I said.

"He told me she was struggling with what happened to me.

That she needed distance."

"Have you spoken to her yourself in the past three years?"

My throat tightened.

"No."

Karen wrote something.

Then she looked up.

"Paula Renner.

That's your sister's name?"

I stared at her.

"How do you know her last name?"

Karen set her pen down on the notebook.

"Because she filed a missing persons report on you fourteen months ago.

And Daniel told the responding officers that you had chosen to cut contact with your family for mental health reasons, and that he had documentation from your therapist to support it." She paused.

"We closed the report.

We shouldn't have."

The sound that came out of me was not a word.

George leaned forward in his chair, his hands pressed together between his knees.

"Paula has been trying to find you," Karen said.

"She never stopped."

My phone buzzed on the bed.

Daniel again.

*Sweetheart, the nurse says this is taking a long time.

Should I come in?

I don't mind waiting with you.*

Karen looked at the phone.

She didn't touch it.

May you like

"Let me tell you what's going to happen next," she said.

"And then I'm going to need you to be very brave."

Related Stories

Other posts