Spotlight

Chapter 5: What Dana Came Armed With

She was already in the kitchen when I came down at seven.

Coffee made.

Two cups.

She slid one toward me without looking up from her phone.

I sat down.

"You wanted to talk."

She set her phone face-down.

"I do." She wrapped both hands around her mug.

"But I want to start by saying I know last night was hard.

I know you love Lily.

I'm not trying to make this about sides."

"All right."

"But there are things I've noticed," she said, "that I haven't brought up because I didn't want to cause problems.

And after last night, I think I have to."

I waited.

"Nia talks to Lily," Dana said.

"Every evening, almost.

In Lily's room with the door closed.

I've heard it — the tone of it, not the words.

But I've also heard Lily repeat things that a nine-year-old wouldn't think of on her own."

"Like what?"

"Like asking me whether Marcus feels more at home here than she does." Dana looked at me.

"She asked me that three weeks ago.

Verbatim.

That is not a nine-year-old's sentence."

"Kids absorb things."

"From somewhere." She held my gaze.

"Nia doesn't like me.

She has never liked me.

She has been patient about it because you're her father and she doesn't want to fight with you directly.

But she has been working on Lily instead."

My jaw was tight.

"That's a serious accusation."

"I know." She said it quietly.

"I've been sitting on it for months because I kept thinking I was misreading it.

But after last night — after what Lily did — I think someone gave her the idea.

I think someone told her, or showed her, that if she made enough noise, you would look at Marcus."

I set my mug down.

"Dana.

Lily said she felt invisible.

She said she told me she felt that way and I dismissed her.

That's on me.

Not on Nia."

"It can be both."

"You're deflecting."

She blinked.

"Excuse me?"

"Your son was in that living room at six in the morning," I said.

"On the camera.

Before Lily.

He picked something up off that shelf and put it back.

He never mentioned it."

The color in Dana's face shifted.

Just slightly.

"That doesn't mean anything."

"Maybe not.

But I asked you to talk and the first thing you did was bring something against Nia." I kept my voice level.

"Why?"

"Because it's true."

"Or because you needed somewhere to point."

She stood up.

"I am trying to protect my son."

"I understand that." I looked at her.

"But last night, in that living room at midnight, you told Marcus that this family would blame him first if something went wrong.

You said it before anything had happened.

And I need to understand what that means."

Dana went very still.

"The camera," I said, "picks up audio."

She said nothing for a long moment.

The refrigerator hummed.

Somewhere upstairs, a floorboard creaked.

"I was venting," she finally said.

"I was tired and I was worried about him.

He doesn't always feel welcome here."

"Does he have a reason to feel that way?"

"Your daughters—"

"Have never been anything but civil to him." I held her gaze.

"I have watched that.

I have been watching it since we got married.

Nia has been careful.

Lily has tried.

If Marcus feels unwelcome, I want to understand why.

But I need you to be honest with me about what happened last night, Dana.

All of it."

She looked at me for a long time.

"You're not going to believe me," she said.

"I'm asking you to try."

She pulled in a breath.

Sat back down.

And for just a moment — a brief and unguarded moment — something moved across her face that looked a lot like fear.

Then Marcus appeared in the kitchen doorway.

He looked at his mother.

May you like

He looked at me.

And then he said, quietly, "I took it."

Related Stories

Other posts