Spotlight

Chapter 7: What Mr. Hutchins Knew

I didn't decide alone.

Mr.

Hutchins came over the next evening with a covered plate of his wife Della's tea cakes and the audio file already organized into three clean segments on a USB drive, labeled in his handwriting with a fine-point pen.

He set the drive on the kitchen table next to the plate.

"Segment one is her crossing the street," he said.

"Segment two is the water and everything after.

Segment three is Gerald's call."

I looked at it.

"Curtis, you didn't have to do all this."

"I've been on this street thirty-two years," he said.

"Della and I moved here when your parents did.

I remember when your mother planted those oaks." He sat down at the table like he'd sat there a hundred times, because he had.

"I also remember when Sandra moved in four years ago and had the Delgado family's fence cited for being two inches over height.

They'd had that fence for eleven years."

Tanya set down two cups of coffee and sat.

"The Delgados," she said.

"I didn't know that."

"They moved," Mr.

Hutchins said.

"Didn't make a fuss.

Just sold and left." He wrapped both hands around his cup.

"After that she went after the Washingtons on the corner.

Said their holiday lights were a fire hazard.

Filed it through the city, not the HOA.

Code enforcement came out and found nothing."

"Did they fight it?" I asked.

"Miriam Washington called me.

I told her to document everything.

She did.

Code enforcement closed it with no action." He paused.

"But Miriam told me later that the whole thing cost her two hundred dollars in time off work and an afternoon with an advisor, just to protect lights she'd had for twenty years."

The kitchen was quiet.

"She picks people she thinks won't push back," Tanya said.

"Or can't," Mr.

Hutchins said.

"The Delgados were worried about their immigration status, even though they were citizens.

Miriam was managing her mother's illness that year.

Sandra knows things.

She watches." He looked at me.

"She's been watching your family since you refinished the driveway last spring.

I saw her standing at her window the whole afternoon you were working."

I thought about the three complaints.

The precision of them.

The timing.

"She wasn't improvising Saturday," I said.

"No," Mr.

Hutchins said.

"She came with a plan.

The bucket was for the complaint.

The lemonade stand accusation was already written in her head.

She wanted a fourth filing by Sunday morning."

Tanya's coffee cup went down on the table.

"Curtis," she said.

"How do you know what she had written?"

Mr.

Hutchins reached into his jacket pocket and set a folded piece of paper on the table.

"Because two weeks ago she asked me to sign a petition," he said.

"Said it was about noise ordinance clarification.

I told her I'd look it over." He nodded at the paper.

"I looked it over."

Tanya unfolded it.

I read it over her shoulder.

It wasn't a noise petition.

It was a letter to the HOA board requesting a formal review of three addresses on our block — the Washingtons, a younger couple two houses down I barely knew named Chen, and us — for, as the letter put it, *persistent failure to maintain community standards consistent with the character of the neighborhood.*

At the bottom was a signature line.

And below that, in small print, a reference to HOA bylaw section 14.3, which covered the process for requesting formal residential review when five or more complaints had been filed.

She had needed signatures to trigger it without the five complaint threshold.

Mr.

Hutchins had been one of them.

"I didn't sign it," he said.

"I told her I needed more time to consider.

Then I called Miriam Washington and I called the Chens.

Neither of them knew they were on the list."

"This is a pattern," Tanya said.

Her voice was very careful.

"This is organized."

"Yes," Mr.

Hutchins said.

I looked at him.

"Curtis, would you be willing to put any of this in writing?

Formally?

If it came to that?"

He picked up his coffee and looked at it for a moment.

"Anthony," he said, "I brought you a USB drive with three labeled audio segments and a petition I kept for two weeks in case I needed it." He looked up.

"What do you think?"

I nodded.

He finished his coffee.

Took one of Della's tea cakes.

Told Tanya the potato salad Saturday had been, in his professional opinion as a man who had eaten a great deal of potato salad, the best on the street by a meaningful margin.

He was at the door when he stopped.

"One more thing," he said.

"Sandra made a call Sunday night.

About an hour after she got home from the HOA meeting.

Long call.

I know because I was on my porch." He paused.

"The person she called.

I heard the name when she started talking."

"Who was it?"

"Fellow named Hargrove," Mr.

Hutchins said.

"Richard Hargrove.

He's on the city planning commission."

The door closed behind him.

Tanya and I looked at each other across the kitchen table, the petition between us, the USB drive beside it, Della's tea cakes going untouched.

"Planning commission," Tanya said slowly.

I pulled out my phone and typed the name.

Richard Hargrove.

City Planning Commission.

Member since 2019.

And before that — before the commission — property attorney.

Fourteen years of practice.

His firm's old website was still cached in a search result.

I clicked it.

The firm's specialty, listed under Practice Areas, was HOA law and residential community governance.

I set the phone on the table.

May you like

Tanya read the screen.

Neither of us said anything for a long time.

Related Stories

Other posts