Chapter 6: What a Real Father Looks Like

Renée answered on the first ring.
She'd been waiting.
"I know," she said before I could speak.
"Dana told me she was going to tell you everything.
I'm so sorry, Marcus.
I should have—"
"Not on the phone," I said.
"Can you come now?"
Thirty-five minutes later she was sitting at my kitchen table, and for the first time in all the years I had known her, she looked small.
She had always been precise, organized, the kind of person who had a plan for the plan.
Tonight her hair was pulled back unevenly and her eyes were swollen in the way that only happens when you've been crying on and off for days and your face has simply given up recovering between rounds.
Dana sat beside her.
Tanya had moved to the kitchen to make tea nobody had asked for.
"Tell me about Joel," I said.
Renée told me.
It took a long time.
Joel Prater.
Thirty-seven.
Civil engineer.
No criminal record, no history of anything a judge would find alarming on paper.
He had ended things with Renée badly, the way some men do — a slow vanishing, no confrontation, just fewer calls and then none.
She had tried once, early in the pregnancy, to reach him.
He hadn't responded.
She had taken that as her answer.
"What changed?" I said.
"His mother," Renée said.
"She's been ill.
She found a photograph — an old one of me and Joel — and apparently started asking questions.
Joel told her everything.
And then she told him she wanted to meet her grandchild before she—" Renée stopped.
"She's been asking him for months.
That's what started this."
"A dying grandmother," I said.
"That's what his lawyer is framing it as.
Family.
Legacy.
Nia deserving to know where she comes from."
I looked at Renée steadily.
"What do you want?"
She looked up.
"I want him to go away.
I want Nia to never have to sit in a courtroom and hear strangers argue about who she belongs to."
"Then we fight it," I said.
"Together."
The relief on her face was immediate and real, and watching it made me feel something complicated — not anger exactly, not anymore, but the particular weight of understanding how long she had carried this alone.
Eight years of knowing.
Eight years of watching me love Nia and carrying that secret alongside it like a second child she could never put down.
I didn't forgive her that night.
But I understood her.
Tanya set four mugs of tea on the table and pulled out her own chair.
Something in her posture was different from the kitchen the night before — the certainty was gone, replaced by something quieter.
"I have a friend," she said.
"Family law.
She's good.
She worked a case two years ago where the bio parent had zero prior involvement.
The court ruled for the established parent."
I looked at her.
"I'll call her tonight," Tanya said.
"If you want."
I held her gaze for a moment.
"Call her."
I left the three of them at the table and drove to my mother's house.
Nia was in the living room watching television, wearing her grandmother's reading glasses as a joke, the frames slipping down her nose.
She pulled them off the moment she saw me and scrambled up.
"Dad.
You're early."
I crouched down to her level.
I didn't say anything for a second.
I just looked at her face — her specific face, the one I had memorized in a hospital room a decade ago, the one I had watched learn to laugh and argue and fall asleep mid-sentence and ask impossible questions about the sky.
"I just wanted to see you," I said.
She squinted at me the way she did when she suspected something was being kept from her.
Then she put her arms around my neck and said nothing.
My mother appeared in the doorway.
She was seventy-one years old and had seen enough of life to read a room without being told what to read.
She looked at my face over Nia's shoulder.
I shook my head slightly.
Not yet.
She nodded once and disappeared back into the kitchen.
On the drive home, Nia fell asleep in the back seat.
I drove slowly, taking the longer way without thinking about it.
When I finally pulled into the driveway and turned off the engine, I sat for a moment in the quiet dark.
Then my phone lit up on the passenger seat.
An unknown number.
A text, one line:
May you like
*She deserves to know her real family.
This doesn't have to be difficult.*