Spotlight

Chapter 5: What Graham's Brother Knew

Fernsby's was small and warm, the kind of café with mismatched chairs and handwritten menus, the smell of good coffee and something baking in the back.

I arrived at ten to nine.

Ros came with me.

I had told her everything on the phone the night before, and she had listened without interrupting, which was how I knew how serious she thought it was.

Clara was already there when we arrived.

A woman in her late thirties, dark hair pulled back, a plain coat, both hands wrapped around a coffee cup.

She looked up when we came in, and her expression was careful but open.

"Juliet," she said.

"This is Ros," I said.

"I hope that's all right."

"Of course." She gestured at the chairs.

"Please."

We sat.

Ros ordered coffee.

I didn't order anything.

"Tell me about Daniel," I said.

Clara nodded.

"Graham's younger brother.

They were close — or they used to be.

Daniel called me about six weeks ago.

Out of the blue.

He had found my number through a friend of a friend.

He said he had been trying to decide whether to get involved and he had finally decided he had to."

"What did he say?"

"He said Graham had been lying to you since almost the beginning." She wrapped her hands tighter around the cup.

"He said the relationship with Sienna started before you were even engaged.

Graham and Sienna met at your birthday dinner — your thirty-second.

Do you remember if Sienna was there?"

My thirty-second birthday.

I had organized it myself.

A restaurant on the waterfront.

I had invited Sienna because she was my sister, even though we weren't close.

She had arrived late and left early and I had barely spoken to her all evening.

Graham had offered to walk her to her taxi.

He had been gone for twenty minutes.

I had thought nothing of it.

"I remember," I said.

"Daniel says it started that night," Clara said.

"Or at least — that's when Graham told him it started."

Ros set her coffee cup down carefully.

"He told his brother?" Ros said.

"Daniel didn't approve," Clara said.

"He told Graham to end it.

Repeatedly.

When Graham got engaged to you instead of ending things with Sienna, Daniel confronted him.

Graham told him to stay out of it.

They stopped speaking at Christmas."

"Does Daniel have proof?" I said.

"Messages.

Anything."

"He has one thing." Clara reached into her bag and placed a phone on the table between us.

An older model.

Cheap.

The kind of phone you buy with cash.

"Graham left this at Daniel's flat during a visit last autumn.

Daniel found it after Graham stopped returning his calls.

He didn't know what to do with it, so he kept it.

He gave it to me when we spoke.

He said — " She paused.

" — he said to give it to the person who needed it most."

I looked at the phone.

"It's locked," Clara said.

"But Daniel told me the code.

He said Graham always used the same four digits." She slid a small folded piece of paper across the table.

"It's your decision what you do with it."

Ros looked at me.

I picked up the phone.

The screen was dark and scratched along one corner.

I unfolded the paper.

Four digits.

I typed them in.

The phone opened.

There were three apps on the home screen.

A messaging app I didn't recognize.

A photo storage app.

And a notes application.

I opened the messages first.

The most recent thread was labeled only with a single letter: *S.*

I scrolled up to find the beginning of the conversation.

The earliest message was dated the night of my thirty-second birthday.

*You looked beautiful tonight.

I haven't stopped thinking about you.*

The reply: *Don't.

She's my sister.*

And then his next message, sent forty minutes later:

*I know.

I can't help it.*

I read the thread.

All of it.

It took eleven minutes.

Ros sat beside me without speaking.

Clara watched the table.

When I put the phone down, my hands were completely steady.

That surprised me.

I had expected them to shake.

"He told her about Portugal," I said.

Not a question.

"Is it in there?" Clara asked.

"He messaged her from the hotel." I kept my voice flat and even.

"While I was sleeping."

Ros made a sound that wasn't a word.

"There's more in the photo app," Clara said quietly.

"I haven't looked at it.

I thought that should be your choice."

"I don't need it," I said.

I had enough.

I placed the phone back on the table, screen-down.

"I need to speak to Daniel directly," I said.

Clara nodded.

"I'll give you his number.

He's expecting you to call."

"One more thing." I looked at her directly.

"When Graham ended your engagement.

What reason did he give?"

Clara looked down at her coffee.

A small, private smile crossed her face — not a happy one.

"He said he had outgrown me," she said.

"That he needed someone with more — ambition."

"I'm sorry," I said.

"Don't be." She looked up.

"He did me the kindest thing he ever did.

I just didn't know it yet."

I picked up the phone from the table and put it in my bag.

Outside, on Aldgate Street, Ros took hold of my arm as we walked.

"Jules," she said.

"What are you going to do?"

"I'm going to call Daniel," I said.

"And then I'm going to speak to a solicitor."

Ros was quiet for a half a step.

"And the gown?" she said.

"Thursday," I said.

"As scheduled."

That evening, Graham called four times.

I didn't answer.

On the fifth call, he left a voicemail.

His voice was low and controlled, the tone I recognized as the one he used when he was working very hard not to sound desperate.

"Jules, I know you're angry.

You have every right to be.

But before you do anything, I think we need to talk.

There are things you don't understand yet.

Things that — " A pause.

"There are things about your family you don't know.

About your mother.

About why she did what she did tonight.

Call me.

Please."

May you like

I listened to it once.

Then I called Daniel.

Related Stories

Other posts