Chapter 8: Marcus Webb's Best Move

Marcus Webb filed a counter-motion on a Wednesday, and Patricia called me before I had finished my first cup of coffee.
"He's going after the inheritance account," she said.
"Webb is arguing that the funds Alexander transferred were used for joint marital expenses and that your father's account, because it was commingled with joint funds over the course of the marriage, should be reclassified as a marital asset."
I set down my cup.
"Can he do that?"
"He can argue it.
It won't hold — the written agreement you both signed at the time of the inheritance is very clear, and we have documentation showing Alexander's transfers were specifically routed to third-party accounts, not household expenses.
But it's a delay tactic.
Webb wants to slow us down and increase your legal costs until you consider settlement."
"I'm not settling."
"I know.
I'm telling you because you need to understand what the next few weeks look like.
It gets louder before it gets quieter."
It got louder.
Alexander's attorney filed two more motions in the following week, each one designed to complicate and extend.
Webb was good at his job — I could see that.
Every filing added paper, added time, added cost.
And underneath the legal maneuvering, I could feel Alexander's actual strategy: exhaust me.
Make the fight expensive enough and long enough that I would eventually decide the settlement was easier.
He had, in some ways, known me well.
The version of me from two weeks ago might have wavered.
But the version of me sitting in Patricia's conference room on a Thursday morning, reading a motion that described my father's inheritance as a marital asset, felt something settle into place that had nothing to do with anger.
"What do we have that Webb doesn't know about?" I asked.
Patricia smiled slightly.
"The recording from Friday night."
I had almost forgotten.
Alexander at my kitchen table, telling me that forty-three families depended on his firm, telling me I would regret this, telling me to give Patricia Hale's name to Marcus Webb.
All of it recorded.
All of it showing a man who had come to my home not to make amends but to assess the threat and negotiate his way out of it.
"Is it usable?"
"In Illinois, yes.
One-party consent.
And there's a specific moment — when he references the crjminal territory and pivots to the employees — that reads as an attempt to discourage you from cooperating with a potential crjminal investigation.
That has its own implications."
"What kind of implications?"
"The kind that Marcus Webb is not going to enjoy explaining to his client."
Patricia submitted the recording as a supplemental exhibit on a Friday.
By Monday morning, Webb had requested an emergency conference with the judge.
I sat in the hallway outside the courtroom and waited.
Ryan sat two seats away from me.
We didn't talk much.
There wasn't much to say.
The conference lasted forty minutes.
When Patricia came out, she was carrying her notepad and walking at her regular pace, but there was something in her expression — not triumph, something quieter than that.
"Webb is recommending his client consider a structured settlement," she said.
"What does that mean?" Ryan asked.
"It means Alexander has seen the recording and he now understands that continuing to fight the civil case while a crjminal referral is active is not in his interest." She looked at me.
"It means he's starting to understand that this isn't going away."
"Is he going to keep fighting?" I asked.
"Webb will try one more thing," she said.
"He always does.
But the shape of this has changed." She paused.
"Claudia, I want you to be prepared for the possibility that Alexander will try to contact you directly before the next hearing.
Not through lawyers.
Personally."
"To do what?"
"To ask you to pull back the crjminal referral.
He'll frame it as doing it for the firm, for the employees, for whatever version of your shared history he thinks still has purchase with you." She looked at me steadily.
"I want you to know that you are under no obligation to respond to that contact.
And if he makes it, I want to know immediately."
I nodded.
Ryan looked at the courtroom door.
"He's still in there?"
"With his attorney, yes."
Ryan stood up.
He straightened his jacket.
May you like
"Good," he said quietly.
"Let him sit with it."