Spotlight

Chapter 3: Everything We Got Wrong About Each Other

"Nobody," Whitney said.

Her voice had changed completely.

Flat.

Careful.

"It sounded like you were on the phone," Mom said.

"Just a work thing.

It can wait."

I sat very still in the hospital bed, the phone pressed against my ear, listening to my mother move through my sister's house.

I could hear the particular sound of her footsteps — the way she walked through a room like she owned it, even when she didn't.

"Come inside," Mom said.

"Your father opened the wine."

"In a minute."

A pause.

"Is everything okay?"

"Fine," Whitney said.

"I just needed some air."

Another pause.

Longer.

"All right," Mom said.

Then the door closed again.

Whitney exhaled.

"She's gone back in."

"How did she sound?" I asked.

"Normal.

That's what frightens me."

I understood that.

Normal was the register my mother used for everything.

She had sounded normal when she told me Whitney didn't want me at her thirtieth.

She had sounded normal when she told me I didn't need to come to Christmas that year because the drive was too long.

She had sounded normal when she said, three days after my daughter was born, that she and Dad would visit when things settled down.

Things had not settled down.

They had not visited.

"Whitney," I said.

"The letter."

"I know."

"Where is it now?"

"My bedroom.

Top drawer of my nightstand.

I've moved it three times because I kept thinking she might find it."

"She doesn't know you have it?"

"I don't think so." A beat.

"But Clara — she was at my desk last week.

She said she was looking for a stamp."

My stomach tightened.

"Did she go through the drawers?"

"I don't know.

I wasn't in the room."

I looked at my daughter sleeping in the carrier beside the bed.

Her chest rose and fell.

Her fist stayed curled against her cheek, the same way it had been for four weeks, the same way it had been in every photograph I had taken alone in my apartment with no one to hand the phone to.

"What does the envelope look like?" I asked.

"Plain white.

Our names are written on the front in Mom's handwriting.

Yours first, then mine.

Like it was addressed to both of us together."

"Has it been opened before?"

"No.

The seal is still intact.

I checked."

"Three years ago," I said.

"What was happening three years ago?"

Whitney was quiet for a moment.

"Your engagement," she said.

"You were engaged to Daniel."

I hadn't thought about Daniel in a long time.

We had been together for two years.

He had proposed on a Tuesday evening in my kitchen, which was not romantic but was very Daniel, and I had said yes, and I had called my mother first, and she had said she was so happy and that she couldn't wait to meet his family.

We had broken off the engagement eight months later.

Mom had told me Whitney thought it was a mistake.

That Whitney had said Daniel was too good for me to walk away from.

Whitney had told me, just now, that she had never said that.

"What did Mom tell you when Daniel and I ended things?" I asked.

"She said you ended it because you were afraid of commitment." Whitney's voice was careful.

"She said Daniel had called her.

That he was heartbroken."

"Daniel never had my mother's number."

Silence.

"She said he found it."

"He didn't have it.

I never gave it to him.

He didn't know her name."

The monitor in the neighboring bay pulsed steadily.

The nurse had stepped out.

The curtain moved slightly in the air from the vent above the door.

"Clara," Whitney said.

"I think I need to open the letter."

"Not tonight.

Not with them in the house."

"I know." Her voice dropped.

"But I need to know what's in it before I see them again.

Before I sit across from them at breakfast tomorrow and pretend I don't know anything."

"They're staying the night?"

"Mom asked if she could.

She said she was tired and didn't want Dad driving after wine." A pause.

"I said yes.

I always say yes."

I understood that too.

"Get through tonight," I said.

"Don't open it while they're there.

Don't give her a reason to look for it."

"And tomorrow?"

"Tomorrow you call me.

First thing.

Before they wake up if you can."

"Okay." She breathed.

"Okay."

"Whitney."

"Yeah."

"I'm sorry about your thirtieth."

She didn't answer immediately.

When she did, her voice was very quiet.

"I'm sorry about your promotion dinner.

I had a dress picked out and everything."

I hadn't known that.

I hadn't known she had planned to come at all.

I had sat at that restaurant for forty minutes and then paid for a bottle of wine I drank alone and told myself it didn't matter.

"We'll talk tomorrow," I said.

"Tomorrow," she agreed.

I ended the call and sat for a moment with the phone in my lap.

The nurse came back in.

She checked the bandage without asking how I was, which I appreciated, and then she looked at the carrier.

"You have a ride?"

"I'm going to call a car."

"You'll need someone at home tonight.

For the lifting."

"I know."

She looked at me for a moment.

Not with pity.

With the particular steadiness of someone who had seen a great many people in emergency rooms at night, alone, making plans they weren't sure they could keep.

"There's a family waiting room down the hall," she said.

"If you need to make more calls before you go."

"Thank you."

She left.

I looked at my daughter.

Four weeks old.

No name for this world yet beyond the one I had given her alone, in this same hospital, in a different room, with no one beside me who shared her bl00d.

I had named her June.

I had not told my parents yet.

I had been waiting for the right moment, and the right moment had not come, and now I understood that it had never been going to come, because the right moment required a family that wanted to receive it.

I picked up my phone again.

I did not call my parents.

I opened my contacts and scrolled past Whitney's name to a number I had not used in four months.

My friend Dara, who had a toddler and worked early, but who had also said, the week June was born, that I should call her if I ever needed anything at all, any hour, and had meant it in the specific way that certain people mean things.

I had said: We're good, thank you.

I pressed call.

She answered on the second ring.

"Clara?

It's almost eleven."

"I know.

I'm sorry."

"What's wrong?"

"I'm at St.

Matthew's.

I need a ride home.

And I might need help with the baby tonight."

Not a pause.

May you like

Not a sigh.

"I'm getting my keys," Dara said.

Related Stories

Other posts