Chapter 5: The Missing Phone

Evelyn pushed herself away from the hospital wall.
“That is impossible.”
Officer Reyes ended the call.
“The lock was intact, but the drawer contained only an unplugged camera hub.”
“Ethan had a second key,” Karen said.
“You knew that?” I asked.
“He told me it was for the wine cabinet.”
Evelyn stared at her daughter.
“You gave him access after what happened in college?”
“You paid for silence.
Don’t pretend you were protecting anyone but the Vance name.”
Officer Reyes raised one hand.
“Where is Ethan now?”
Graham approached from the elevators.
“He left the estate through the kitchen while the officers were securing the room.”
Professor Ward followed him.
“He called me from the parking lot and offered me fifty thousand dollars to say Lily admitted falling.”
“He tried to bribe you?” Karen whispered.
Professor Ward held up her phone.
“The call was recorded by my university voicemail system.”
Karen sank into a chair.
“Ethan would never—”
“You heard him lie in that dining room,” I said.
“How many lies must he tell before you stop finishing them for him?”
My phone rang.
The screen showed Ethan’s name.
Officer Reyes said, “Answer on speaker.”
I pressed the button.
“Where are you?”
“Somewhere your friends cannot reach me.”
“Lily is in surgery.”
“And my life is being destroyed over one stupid shove.”
“You harmed an eight-year-old.”
“Karen made it worse, not me.
Give me access to the tuition account and tell the police you overreacted.
Then I’ll return the phone.”
“What is on it?”
A pause followed.
“Nothing you need to see.”
Evelyn stepped toward the phone.
“Ethan, I kept that device because you promised you had changed.”
“You kept it to control me, Grandma.”
“I protected you.”
“No, you enjoyed being needed.”
Karen snatched the phone from my hand.
“Ethan, come to the hospital.
We can still fix this.”
“Wire me two hundred thousand dollars.”
“I don’t have that.”
“Grandma does.”
Evelyn’s mouth opened, but no words came.
Ethan continued, “If I don’t receive it within an hour, the phone goes into the Hudson, and I release every letter proving Aunt Alexandra funded me.
I’ll say she expected favors when I joined Graham’s firm.”
Graham leaned toward the speaker.
“There was no position to exchange for favors.”
“You’ll defend a judge before a student.
People will believe power protects power.”
The call ended.
Karen thrust the phone back at me.
“Pay him.”
“No.”
“He is frightened.”
“So is Lily.”
“You can replace the money!”
Professor Ward stepped between us.
“You still think money is the loss that matters?”
The surgical doors opened.
Dr.
Patel removed his cap.
“Lily’s leg is stabilized,” he said.
“The damage was severe, but the procedure went well.”
I covered my mouth.
“Can I see her?”
“As soon as recovery calls.
There is something else.
The pattern of the second inj*ry is medically distinct from the first.”
Officer Reyes opened his notebook.
“Can you document that?”
“I already have.”
Karen backed into the wall.
“You told me you barely touched her,” Evelyn said.
“I was angry,” Karen whispered.
“She was screaming, and Ethan’s guests were coming.”
“You harmed that child to protect a dinner announcement?”
“You taught me that Ethan came first!”
Evelyn’s face folded.
“And you obeyed.”
Officer Reyes’s phone buzzed with a message.
He turned the screen toward me.
A traffic camera showed Ethan’s car entering the hospital garage.
“He came back,” I said.
“No,” Officer Reyes replied.
May you like
“According to security, he isn’t alone.”
On the screen, a man in a dark suit stepped from the passenger side carrying Lily’s red school folder.