Spotlight

Chapter 5: The Woman in Florida

Her full name was Diane Calloway.

Maiden name Hurst.

Alicia and Nina's mother by birth, and by almost nothing else, from what Nina told me over the next hour.

She had left when Alicia was eleven and Nina was fifteen.

No dramatic event, no single confrontation.

She had simply reorganized her life in a direction that didn't include her daughters.

She moved south, remarried twice, and surfaced occasionally in the form of birthday cards that arrived late or not at all.

"She came to the hospital once," Nina said.

"About a month before Alicia died.

Alicia asked her to leave."

"Why did she come?"

"I've been asking myself that since." Nina refilled her tea.

She didn't offer me more.

I hadn't touched the first cup.

"At the time I thought it was guilt.

Now I think someone must have mentioned the baby."

"Someone who knew."

"The hospital has records.

Alicia delivered Grace at a different hospital, across town, in January.

She registered the birth without a father's name.

Diane has connections I don't fully understand.

People she knows from her second marriage who know people." Nina's voice stayed flat, reporting the facts with the patience of someone who has already spent weeks being frightened by them.

"Her lawyer sent me a letter three weeks ago.

I didn't tell you because Alicia had asked me to wait until after the funeral."

"But you're telling me now."

"Because now you know about Grace.

And because Diane's lawyer sent a second letter yesterday."

She got up and went to the kitchen.

She came back with an envelope and held it out to me.

I opened it.

The language was formal and precise in the way that legal language is precise — built to sound reasonable while meaning something not reasonable at all.

It cited Alicia's death, the absence of a registered father, the grandmother's desire to provide stability for the child, the grandmother's financial resources and established residence.

It requested that Nina voluntarily transfer temporary care arrangements pending a formal hearing.

It was dated two days ago.

"She doesn't know about the marriage," I said.

"No."

"She doesn't know Alicia and I were legally married."

"No.

It was a hospital ceremony.

It wasn't announced.

The paperwork was filed but it's not something Diane would have found yet."

I folded the letter carefully and put it back in the envelope.

"Which means she doesn't know that Grace's father is also Alicia's legal husband.

Which means she doesn't know that the father has standing."

Nina watched me.

"She's about to find out," I said.

"Lucas." Nina's voice was careful again, the rehearsed-conversation voice.

"Before you do anything — I need you to understand what Diane is like.

She doesn't respond to reason.

She responds to pressure and to the appearance of winning.

She has a lawyer who is very good at drawing things out.

Even losing cases can take months."

"I'm a doctor, Nina.

I'm thirty years old and I have no criminal record and I am Grace's biological father and I was legally married to her mother.

I have more standing than Diane has grounds."

"I know that."

"Then why do you look like you're about to tell me to be careful?"

"Because I am." She leaned forward slightly.

"She's going to make this ugly if she thinks she's losing.

She already knows things — or she'll claim to know things — about the relationship between you and Alicia.

You were her doctor.

That's not going to look simple.

She'll use it."

The room was quiet for a moment.

Grace made a sound in the crib.

Not waking — just the small unconscious noises of a baby adjusting.

I looked over at her and then back at Nina.

"Did Alicia know about Diane's letter?" I said.

"No.

Diane sent it after Alicia was gone."

"So Alicia died thinking Grace was safe."

Nina's expression shifted.

Just slightly.

"Yes."

I stood up.

"Then I'm going to make sure she was right."

I picked up the envelope.

Nina stood too, and for a moment we were both just standing in a room with a sleeping baby and a letter and a problem that Alicia had not lived long enough to see coming.

"There's one more thing," Nina said.

I waited.

"Diane is coming here.

Not soon — but soon enough.

Her lawyer mentioned a site visit.

They want to assess the living situation before the hearing." Nina paused.

"That means she'll be here in person.

And when she finds out about you—"

"She'll escalate."

"Yes."

I nodded once.

"Good," I said.

"Let her."

Nina looked at me for a moment with something in her expression that I hadn't seen there before.

"Alicia always said you were the most dangerously calm person she had ever met," she said.

May you like

"She was right."

I put the envelope in my coat pocket and said goodnight to Grace, who did not hear me, and walked back out to my car in the dark.

Related Stories

Other posts