Chapter 8: The Call He Shouldn't Have Made

Diane rang me at seven in the morning.
"He called me last night," she said.
"Martin."
I was already awake.
I had been awake since five.
"What did he say?"
"He was polite at first.
Very measured.
He said he understood I was considering appearing at the hearing and that he wanted to have a conversation before that happened." Her voice was steady, but I could hear something underneath it.
"He said that if I appeared, his lawyers would pursue an abandonment finding.
That they would make sure the court had full documentation of the fact that I left Alicia when she was six months old and made no contact for six years."
"That's leverage," I said.
"He's trying to scare you off."
"I know." A pause.
"Then he said something else."
I waited.
"He said that he had spoken to someone at child services.
That if the current arrangements remained contested and no stable guardian was confirmed before the hearing, there was a possibility the court would place Alicia in temporary foster care while the case was resolved." Her voice tightened on the last four words.
"He said he was just making sure I understood the full picture."
My free hand pressed flat against the counter.
"He threatened to put her in foster care," I said.
"He presented it as a neutral possibility.
But yes."
I turned toward the hallway.
Alicia's door was closed.
I could hear her moving around inside.
The small sounds of a child waking up.
Socks on the floor.
A drawer.
"He's trying to panic us," I said.
"Into settling before the hearing."
"Is he wrong?
About the foster care risk?"
"I'll call Ruth in twenty minutes."
"I recorded the call," Diane said.
I stopped moving.
"The whole call," she said.
"I turned on the recording the moment he said he wanted to talk about the hearing.
I have everything — including the part where he mentions the child services contact by name."
The hallway was quiet for a moment.
Then Alicia opened her door and padded into the kitchen in her socks, her hair loose, her eyes still half-closed.
"You're on the phone," she said.
"One more minute, sweetheart."
She went to the cupboard and took out a bowl by herself, carefully, and put it on the counter.
"Diane," I said quietly.
"Send the recording to Ruth.
Right now.
Before anything else."
"Already done," she said.
"Twenty minutes ago."
---
Ruth called at seven forty-five.
"The recording changes everything," she said without preamble.
"Contacting the opposing party directly, implying he's already influenced a child services representative — his lawyers are going to have a very bad morning when I file this."
"Can we use it in the hearing?"
"I'm going to file it as evidence today.
And I'm going to request that the judge be informed of the contact before we even walk into that courtroom." A pause.
"Martin just handed us the frame.
A man who would call the biological mother the night before a custody hearing and threaten her with foster care to protect his access to a trust fund — that is not the picture of a devoted uncle."
"His lawyers will say he was just informing her of risks."
"His lawyers will say a lot of things.
But the recording captures his tone, his phrasing, and the name of a child services contact he claims to have already spoken to.
That last piece — that's the one I'm most interested in." Her voice sharpened slightly.
"If he actually made that contact, that's improper influence on an open case.
And if he fabricated it to frighten her, that's something else."
"Either way —"
"Either way, it's his voice.
His words.
His choice to make that call."
Alicia was eating her cereal across the kitchen.
She'd poured it herself, spilled a little, wiped it up without being asked.
"Ruth," I said, "is she safe?
Before the hearing?"
"I filed an emergency motion this morning to confirm the current arrangements pending the hearing.
The judge will see it today.
As long as you are present and providing care, no one removes her without a court order." A pause.
"And Martin would have to explain that recording to a judge before he gets one."
I watched Alicia eat her cereal.
She looked up and caught me watching her.
"You're doing that thing again," she said.
"What thing?"
"The looking thing.
Where you look at me too much."
"Sorry."
She considered this.
"It's okay," she said.
"Mrs.
Okafor does it too."
She went back to her cereal.
I went back to breathing.
The hearing was in four days.
Martin's lawyers called Ruth's office three times before noon and received no response.
The fourth call, Ruth picked up herself.
"My client has nothing to discuss before the hearing," she said.
"We'll see you in court."
May you like
She told me later that the line had gone very quiet after that.
Good.