Chapter 9: Samuel Price

It was Richard.
"We found Samuel Price."
"Is he all right?"
A pause that lasted one second too long.
"He's alive.
He's been in a private care facility in Vermont.
His daughter moved him there after the accident.
She was frightened — he'd told her about Caroline's investigation.
She took him off the grid."
"Can we reach him?"
"His daughter spoke to Agent Okafor twenty minutes ago.
She's agreed to allow a visit.
Okafor wants to go tomorrow.
She's asking if you'll come."
"Yes," I said.
"There's something else." Another pause.
"Gerald Marsh called the senator's office tonight.
After hours.
He left a message."
I sat up.
"What did he say?"
"He said, and I'm quoting the message directly — 'Tell the senator I want to talk.
Not through lawyers.
Directly.
I think there's a version of this that doesn't have to be as bad as it's heading.'"
I held the phone and thought about that.
"He's looking for an exit," I said.
"That's what Okafor thinks.
She wants to let him sit overnight before anyone responds."
"Agreed."
I didn't go back to sleep.
Samuel Price was eighty-one.
He sat in a chair by the window of his room at the care facility with a blanket across his knees and his hands folded in his lap.
He was thinner than his photographs, and his eyes had the slightly unfocused quality of a man whose body had been giving him trouble.
But when Okafor sat down across from him and introduced herself and explained why we'd come, his gaze sharpened immediately.
"I've been waiting for this," he said.
"For a long time."
His daughter, a woman in her mid-fifties named Ruth, stood near the door with her arms folded.
"I told him to let this go years ago," she said quietly.
"He wouldn't."
"I couldn't," Price said, without looking away from Okafor.
"I never signed those documents.
I told Gerald Marsh that in 1994 when I first found my name on them.
He said it was a clerical error.
That it would be corrected." He paused.
"It was never corrected.
And when I pushed, he told me that drawing attention to it would only make things worse for me.
That I had no idea what the full picture looked like and I should trust that it was being handled."
"Did he threaten you?" Okafor asked.
"Not directly.
Gerald was never direct.
But the implication was clear." Price's hands unfolded slowly.
"I had a practice.
A family.
A career I had spent thirty years building.
I told myself it was a clerical error.
I told myself that enough times that I eventually almost believed it."
"And then Caroline contacted you," I said.
He looked at me properly for the first time.
"She found me through a colleague.
She was careful.
Very careful.
She explained what she had found, what she was building." He paused.
"She sounded like someone who was going to finish what she started."
"She nearly did," I said.
Price looked at his hands again.
"When I heard about the accident — Ruth called me.
I knew."
"You knew it wasn't an accident?" Okafor asked.
"I knew that the timing was not a coincidence," he said precisely.
"I am not a conspiracy man, Agent Okafor.
I have always believed in evidence.
But some things you know in your bones before the evidence arrives."
"I need you to give a formal statement," Okafor said.
"Your account of what happened in 1994.
What Marsh said to you.
What you found.
Everything you told Caroline."
"I'll give you anything you need." He straightened in his chair.
"I'm eighty-one years old.
I'm not afraid of Gerald Marsh anymore."
Ruth made a sound near the door.
Not quite a word.
"Ruth." He looked at his daughter.
"It has to be done."
She didn't answer.
But she dropped her arms from across her chest, and that was enough.
On the drive back, Okafor received a call.
She listened, spoke three short sentences, and ended it.
"Gerald Marsh," she said, "just retained a new attorney.
His third this year."
"That means he's serious about talking," I said.
"Or serious about protecting himself while appearing to talk." She looked out the window.
"Either way, it means Warren Colfield doesn't know what Marsh is doing.
That gap is what we need."
"How do we use it?"
"We let Marsh believe he has an opportunity.
We let him walk in thinking he can negotiate." She turned to look at me directly.
"And we make sure that when he walks in, we already have more than he thinks we have."
We drove in silence for a while.
Then I said: "Caroline figured it all out from a distance.
Without Okafor's resources.
Without a federal badge.
Just her, a laptop, and two years of quiet work."
Okafor nodded once.
"She was good."
May you like
"She was extraordinary," I said.
Neither of us said anything after that.