Spotlight

Chapter 5: What Patricia Had Already Done

Monday came fast.

I called my attorney, Diane, at eight in the morning.

She picked up on the second ring and listened without interrupting, which was one of the reasons I trusted her.

When I finished, she was quiet for a moment.

"She filed three weeks ago," Diane said.

"That's what the letter says."

"And you're only seeing it now."

"Ryan brought it Saturday.

In person.

After spending the afternoon at my house."

Another pause.

Longer this time.

"Sarah, I need you to send me everything.

The letter, the envelope, any other correspondence.

And then I need you to tell me whether Ryan has had any other access to Rosie since the divorce was finalized."

I told her about the visitation schedule we'd agreed on informally.

No court order.

Just an arrangement between us, written in a text thread and kept reasonably well.

Diane's silence had a shape to it.

"That informal arrangement," she said, "is part of what Patricia is using."

"Using how?"

"Her petition argues that Rosie has an established relationship with the paternal grandparent and that denying continued contact would cause emotional harm." A short pause.

"She's listed several visits where she was present.

She's described them in some detail."

My hand tightened on the phone.

"She kept notes," I said.

"It appears so."

I sat down.

Rosie was in her bouncer on the kitchen table, watching the light come through the window.

I'd been watching her watch the light when Diane picked up.

It felt like a different morning now.

"Diane, what are my actual options here?"

"You can respond formally and contest the petition.

Given that there's no prior court order and no documented evidence of a significant independent relationship between Rosie and Patricia — meaning time spent alone, without Ryan present — the petition is weak.

But weak isn't dismissed."

"And if I don't contest it?"

"Then a judge schedules a hearing and Patricia gets to tell her version first."

"What's her version?"

Diane paused again.

The careful kind.

"I've seen the initial filing.

Patricia's attorney describes you as, and I'm reading directly now, 'an emotionally unstable single mother who has used the marital separation to systematically limit the child's access to her father's family.'"

I didn't say anything.

"Sarah."

"I'm here."

"This is a legal strategy.

It's designed to make you angry enough to respond badly.

Don't respond badly."

"I won't."

"I know you won't.

But I need to say it." A pause.

"I also need to tell you something else.

Something I found this morning after you called."

I waited.

"Patricia filed an affidavit," Diane said, "signed two weeks ago, in which she describes in detail a visit she claims to have made to your home.

Alone.

Without Ryan.

She says you invited her in, that you expressed distress about your ability to care for Rosie, and that you made statements suggesting you were struggling beyond normal new-mother difficulties."

My throat went cold.

"I never invited Patricia into my home."

"I know.

But she's described the layout of your living room.

The color of the couch.

The bouncer.

The diaper bag."

I looked at the bouncer on my kitchen table.

"Ryan," I said.

"That would be my assumption," Diane said.

"He described it to her and she built an affidavit around someone else's details."

"Can she do that?"

"She did do that.

Whether it holds up is a different question." A beat.

"Sarah, do you have any security cameras?

Any record of who came and went from your home?"

I thought about Mrs.

Patterson.

I thought about the way she had appeared on my porch on Saturday, arms crossed, shaking her head.

May you like

I thought about how she had stayed in my doorway the entire time Ryan was there.

"I might," I said, "have something better than a camera."

Related Stories

Other posts