Spotlight

Chapter 4: What Robert Left Behind

The kitchen smelled like coffee and morning light.

Jake sat at the far end of the table — the seat that had always been David's growing up.

He wrapped both hands around his mug the way Robert used to.

I noticed it and said nothing.

"Start from the beginning," I said.

"Your beginning."

He nodded.

"My mother, Carol, met your husband in 1987.

She was twenty-six.

He was forty-three." He paused.

"She wasn't naive.

She knew he was married.

She said she told herself it was temporary."

"Was it?"

"It lasted almost four years."

Four years.

Sarah had been in high school.

David had been in college.

I had been here, in this house, running a household and volunteering at the hospital auxiliary and driving to Robert's office with his forgotten lunch.

Four years.

"He ended it when Carol found out she was pregnant?"

"Two months before she told him." Jake set his mug down.

"He ended it because he said he couldn't keep doing it to you.

That was what she told me.

She wasn't bitter about it.

She always said it like it meant something — that he had stopped because of you."

The coffee was too hot.

I drank it anyway.

"He knew about you," I said.

It wasn't a question.

"He found out when I was three months old.

Carol wrote to him.

He wrote back once." Jake reached into the inside pocket of his jacket — that jacket, always full of things — and produced a single folded page.

The paper was old.

The fold lines were soft with age.

"She kept this, too."

He slid it across the table.

Robert's handwriting.

I would have known it anywhere — that particular slant, the way his capital letters were always slightly larger than necessary.

*Carol — I cannot be what you need me to be.

I cannot be what he deserves.

I know that.

I am sending what I can and will continue to do so.

Please don't write again.

If something ever changes, Linda will reach me.

I am sorry.

I am more sorry than I know how to say.

— R.*

I read it twice.

Then I set it flat on the table and smoothed the fold with my thumb.

"He sent money?" I asked.

"Every month.

Until he d*ed." Jake watched me carefully.

"I didn't know where it came from until my mother told me, right before the end.

She said she had always told me it was from a trust my grandfather had set up.

I believed her." He shook his head slightly.

"She didn't want me to resent him."

"Did you?

When you found out?"

A long pause.

"I wanted to.

It seemed like the right thing to feel." He looked out the window toward the backyard.

"But then I found the shoebox and read his letter and looked at all those photographs of this house — Christmas lights on the porch, your daughter in a cap and gown, your grandson's first birthday — and I just thought, he was watching from a distance too.

He was paying for me and watching from a distance.

Same as my mother watched from a distance." He turned back to me.

"Everyone was watching each other from a distance.

And nobody was actually there."

The kitchen was very quiet.

Outside, a mockingbird was going through its entire repertoire in the orange tree beside the patio.

"What do you want, Jake?" I asked.

"Not what your mother wanted for you.

Not what your lawyer told you to want.

What do you want?"

He didn't answer immediately.

That was the first moment I fully trusted him — that he didn't have an answer ready.

"I want to know if I look like him," he said finally.

"People who knew him.

I want someone who actually knew him to look at me and tell me if I look like him." His jaw tightened slightly.

"And I want to know what he was like.

Not the letter version.

The real version.

What he ate for breakfast.

What made him laugh.

Whether he was kind." He stopped.

"Was he kind?"

I thought about fifty-one years.

I thought about the letter on the hallway table.

I thought about Linda's grocery lists on the counter and the man who had stood in a photograph with another family and looked more relaxed than I had ever seen him.

"He was careful," I said.

"He was generous when he felt safe.

He was funny, privately — he wouldn't perform for a room, but he would make me laugh in the car on the way home." I paused.

"He was not always brave.

But he tried, at the end.

I think he tried."

Jake nodded.

His throat moved.

The back door opened.

Sarah walked in.

She hadn't knocked.

She never knocked — this was still the house she'd grown up in, and old habits are immune to shame.

She looked at the letter on the table.

Then at Jake.

Then at me.

"I should have told you," she said.

"I know that."

"Yes," I said.

"I was nineteen.

He sat me down and he cried, Mom.

I had never seen Dad cry before.

He said he had made a terrible mistake and that you would leave him and it would destroy the family and he needed me to—" She stopped.

She pressed the back of her hand to her mouth.

"He made you carry it," I said.

"Yes."

"That wasn't fair to you either."

Sarah looked at me sharply.

Like she hadn't expected that.

Like she had come in braced for something harder.

"It still wasn't yours to decide for me," I added.

"Either of you."

"No," she said quietly.

"It wasn't."

Jake was looking at his coffee mug.

Giving us what space he could across a small kitchen table.

"What was the welfare assessment for?" I asked Sarah.

"The two men you brought."

Her eyes dropped.

"David called a family attorney last week.

He said that if Jake had somehow manipulated you — financially, legally — we needed documentation.

The men were from a private firm.

They were going to assess your mental state and—"

"Determine whether I was competent."

"Yes."

I let that sit between us for a moment.

"David arranged this."

"He's scared, Mom.

He's been scared since I called him and told him Jake had found me." She looked at Jake directly for the first time since she'd walked in.

"He's also known his entire adult life that there might be an inheritance claim.

That a half-sibling could appear and complicate everything."

Jake's head came up.

"I haven't made any claim.

I don't want the money."

"David doesn't know that."

"Then someone should tell him."

The back door opened again.

David walked in.

He was breathing hard, like he'd rushed from his car.

His tie was loosened.

His face was the color of old chalk.

He looked at Jake the way a man looks at something he has been dreading for a very long time.

"Mom," he said.

"I can explain—"

"I know," I said.

"Sit down, David."

He sat.

He looked at the letter on the table and went perfectly still.

"That's Dad's handwriting," he said.

"Yes."

"Where did—" He stopped.

He looked at Jake.

Something moved across his face — not exactly guilt, not exactly grief.

Something older than either.

Something that had been living inside him, quietly, since he was twenty-two years old.

"How much does she know?"

"Everything," Jake said simply.

David put both elbows on the table and dropped his face into his hands.

Outside, the mockingbird had moved on.

The orange tree was quiet.

I poured a third cup of coffee and set it in front of my son.

May you like

"Drink that," I said.

"And then we're going to talk."

Related Stories

Other posts