Chapter 3: What My Mother Wrote

It was my mother's handwriting.
I had not spoken to her in four years.
Not since the week we brought Sophie home from the hospital, when she stood in our living room, looked at Sophie's face for the first time, and said, very quietly but very clearly, "You should look into options."
Grace had asked her to leave.
I had said nothing.
That silence had cost me my marriage nearly as much as the two words I had whispered in the delivery room.
My mother had sent one letter, eight months after Sophie was born.
I had read it once, folded it back up, and put it in the filing cabinet in my home office.
I had never shown it to Grace.
I had told myself I was protecting everyone.
What I was really doing was protecting myself from having to explain how long I had let that woman stay in my life before finally letting her go.
I looked at the paper on the table.
"Where did you get this, Sophie?"
"I found it," she said.
"In your office.
The bottom drawer.
I was looking for tape."
Grace set down the dish towel.
"What is it?" she asked.
I picked it up.
My hands were steadier than I expected.
I unfolded it slowly and read the first line out loud before I could stop myself.
*"The birthmark will define her entire life, and you know it.
There are clinics in Europe.
No one has to know.
This is not cruelty — this is love."*
The kitchen was absolutely still.
Sophie was watching me.
Five years old, her small hands flat on the table, waiting.
"Daddy," she said.
"What does define mean?"
I set the letter face-down.
"It means someone thought they knew what your life was going to be like," I said.
"Before you even had a chance to live it."
"Who wrote it?"
I looked at Grace.
Grace looked at me.
Five years of an unspoken agreement sat between us — we had never brought my mother into the house, not even in conversation, not around Sophie.
"Someone who was wrong," I said.
Sophie considered this for a moment.
Then she looked at the letter, then back at me.
"Was she wrong about you too?" she asked.
"In the video.
Were you being like her?"
The question went through me like something cold.
Grace turned back to the sink.
I heard the water running again, but I could see her shoulders.
They were not moving the way they did when she was just washing dishes.
"I was scared," I said.
"I was wrong to be scared.
And I have spent every single day since then trying to be better than that one second."
Sophie nodded slowly, the way children do when they are filing something away carefully.
"Okay," she said.
That was it.
Just okay.
She picked up the letter, folded it back along its original creases, and held it out to me.
"You should probably put this somewhere she can't find it again," Grace said from the sink, her voice completely flat.
I took the letter.
I looked at my daughter's face — that birthmark, that sweep of dark across her left cheek — and I thought about the word define, and what my mother had meant by it, and what Sophie had just done to that word without even knowing.
I stood up.
"I'm going to do something with this," I said.
"And then I want to tell you both something.
About that night.
All of it."
Grace turned off the tap.
Sophie put her hands in her lap and waited.
I walked to the kitchen trash can, pressed the lid open, and dropped the letter in.
Then my phone buzzed on the counter.
I glanced at the screen out of habit.
May you like
It was my mother's number.
For the first time in four years.