Chapter 6: The Man Who Knew the Door

My father read the message twice.
He set the phone down on the table and pushed it back toward Nicole with two fingers, slowly, like it was something that needed to be returned to its owner.
"He's been holding this over you," he said.
"For about eight months.
Since he found out I remarried."
"Found out how?"
Nicole's mouth pressed into a thin line.
"He has a friend who knew someone from my old neighborhood.
Word travels."
"And what exactly did he threaten to tell me?"
"Everything I just told you.
The loan.
The money.
The letter." She paused.
"He found out about the letter somehow.
I don't know how.
He said if I didn't confess to you myself, he would send you the documents he had."
"What documents?"
"The transfer records.
From when your first wife moved the money to my account.
He said he had a copy."
My father looked at her steadily.
"How would Paul have a copy of a private bank transfer from eleven years ago?"
Nicole said nothing.
"Nicole." His voice was very quiet.
"Think carefully before you answer me.
How would a man you divorced seven years ago have access to a document that existed before you met me?"
The silence in the kitchen was different now.
It wasn't the silence of shock or grief.
It was the silence of a question that had only one answer, and nobody at the table wanting to be the first to say it.
I said it.
"He didn't find it through a friend," I said.
"He found it because you still have contact with him.
Real contact.
Not occasional calls you don't answer."
Nicole looked at me.
Her face was pale.
"How long?" I asked.
"It's not what you're thinking."
"How long have you been in contact with him?"
"He contacts me.
I don't reach out to him.
There's a difference."
"Is there?" My father stood up from the table.
He walked to the window and stood with his back to both of us for a moment, looking out at the yard.
"A man has documents about my first wife's private accounts.
Documents he could only have if someone gave them to him or showed them to him.
And you're telling me the difference between him reaching out to you and you reaching out to him is meaningful."
"I never gave him anything."
"Then how does he have it?"
"I don't know."
"Nicole."
"I don't know, David." Her voice rose for the first time.
"He's Paul.
He finds things.
He has always found things.
That's who he is, that's what he does, and I have spent seven years trying to get far enough away from him that he stops finding things, and it hasn't worked." She pressed both hands flat on the table.
"I married you and I thought — I genuinely thought that would be the end of it.
That he would see I had moved on and he would stop."
"But he didn't."
"No.
He didn't."
My father turned around.
He looked at her for a long time.
"I need to make a phone call," he said.
"I need to call someone who can tell me what our legal options are regarding this man."
Nicole stared at him.
"You're calling a lawyer."
"I'm calling a lawyer."
"David, I don't think — "
"He has private financial documents that belong to my family," my father said.
His voice was completely level.
"He has been using them to threaten my wife.
Whether or not I am angry with you right now — and I am — that does not change what he has done.
And it does not change the fact that he is apparently willing to do more."
He picked up his phone from the counter.
Not the one on speaker.
His own.
"Wait," Nicole said.
"There's more?" I asked.
She looked between us.
Her hands were shaking now, a fine tremor she was trying to control by pressing them harder against the table.
"He called this morning," she said.
"Before your grandmother.
Before everything.
He said the documents weren't the only thing he had."
My father stopped.
"He said he had something else.
Something he's been holding for a long time." She looked at me, and her eyes were full of something I wasn't ready to name.
"He said it was about your mother.
About why she chose me to hold the letter.
And he said if I didn't tell you myself today, he was going to come here."
The front door.
May you like
My eyes went to it automatically.
As if on cue, from somewhere outside on the front porch, came three slow knocks.