Spotlight

Chapter 8: The Filing

The competency petition arrived at the courthouse the following morning.

Grace Holloway — Eleanor's attorney, a composed woman in her fifties who had driven four hours from the city the moment Patricia called — was already seated at the hospital conference table with a cup of tea and a file folder when Renata brought the news.

"I expected it," Grace said.

She didn't look up from the folder.

"He filed faster than I thought, which tells me he's more worried than he's letting on."

"Can he succeed?" Patricia asked.

She was sitting across from Grace, still in the same travel jacket, her carry-on still against the wall.

"He needs two physicians to certify she lacks capacity.

He'll have already approached someone." Grace finally looked up.

"Eleanor.

How many doctors have you seen in the last fourteen months?"

Eleanor was seated at the head of the table.

The hospital had given her a robe and slippers and she wore them with the dignity of a woman sitting in a boardroom.

"My general practitioner, Dr.

Fenn.

She retired in September.

Her replacement, a Dr.

Carver, saw me twice." She paused.

"Martin recommended Dr.

Carver."

Grace wrote the name down.

"Anyone else?"

"A specialist Martin arranged.

A Dr.

Whitmore.

He spoke to me for about twenty minutes.

He asked me what year it was, who the president was, what I'd had for breakfast.

He wrote something down and Martin thanked him very much."

Grace's pen stopped.

"Dr.

Whitmore," she said.

"Did he give you any paperwork?"

"No."

Grace looked at Renata.

Renata looked at Okafor.

Something passed between them without words.

"He's on the petition," Renata said.

"Listed as one of the certifying physicians."

Grace closed her folder.

"Then we have a problem, and also a solution.

The problem is Martin will try to get this in front of a judge before we can challenge it.

The solution is that Eleanor's two independent assessments from fourteen months ago are part of the court record.

Dr.

Whitmore's evaluation was neither independent nor properly disclosed." She picked up her tea.

"We file a challenge by end of day.

We request an emergency evaluation by a court-appointed physician.

And we ask the judge to look at who recommended Dr.

Whitmore to the family."

"He'll fight it," Patricia said.

"Of course he will." Grace looked at Eleanor.

"They almost always fight it.

But they almost always lose, because by the time they're filing competency petitions they've already done enough other things to make the judge suspicious."

Eleanor looked at the table.

At her folded hands.

"Martin was a sweet boy," she said.

It came out quietly, without warning, without self-pity.

Just a fact that had been sitting in the room all along.

"He was a sweet boy until he wasn't.

I don't know exactly when that changed.

I've spent a great deal of time trying to identify the moment." She looked up.

"I never can."

No one spoke for a moment.

Then Patricia said, quietly: "It doesn't matter when it changed, Gran."

Eleanor looked at her.

"It matters what he does next," Patricia said.

"That's the only part we can still affect."

The competency challenge was filed at two-seventeen that afternoon.

At four-oh-five, Martin's attorney called Grace's office and left a voicemail.

Grace played it on speaker, in the conference room, with Renata and Okafor present.

Martin's attorney's voice, careful and unhurried: *Mrs.

Holloway.

My client is open to a conversation about an arrangement that would satisfy everyone's concerns without the need for protracted litigation.

He's prepared to be generous.

He simply asks that certain — records — be treated as a family matter rather than a public one.

I think you'll find his terms reasonable.

Please call me at your earliest convenience.*

Grace stopped the recording.

She looked at the table.

"He's offering a bribe," Patricia said flatly.

"He's offering a settlement conversation," Grace said, with the slight emphasis of a woman who knew exactly what it was.

"Which we will decline." She picked up her phone.

"And which Renata will now document as an attempt to interfere with a criminal investigation."

Renata was already writing.

That evening, the judge assigned to the competency petition scheduled an emergency hearing for forty-eight hours out.

And Dr.

Whitmore, Renata informed us the next morning, had a prior complaint filed against him from two years ago — a different family, a different elderly patient, a competency certification that had later been overturned.

A different family.

May you like

The same attorney.

Martin's attorney.

Related Stories

Other posts