Chapter 7: Thirty-Seven Messages

I didn't sleep.
I lay in Renata's spare room in the dark with my phone on the pillow beside me and my daughter pressing steadily against my ribs, and at two in the morning I opened Cole's email.
The password worked.
I sat up slowly and turned on the bedside lamp.
It took me eleven minutes to find the folder.
He had labelled it with a single initial.
D.
Thirty-seven messages.
The oldest was dated eight months ago, two weeks after the cancelled paternity consultation.
The most recent was dated four days before the baby shower.
I read them in order.
The first few were careful.
Formal, almost.
Darla expressing regret.
Cole responding in short sentences, wary.
But by the fifth message, the register had shifted.
She had found his frequency.
She asked him questions about himself — his childhood, his fears, his frustrations with work.
He answered them.
Each answer got longer.
By the twelfth message, she was calling him the name only his closest friends used.
By the twentieth, she was describing what she called a connection that she had never expected and did not quite know what to do with.
By the thirty-first, she had written: *I know this is wrong.
I know what I'm asking.
But I think you feel it too.
And I think she would understand, eventually, if she knew the whole truth.*
I read that sentence three times.
*If she knew the whole truth.*
I scrolled back to the beginning.
I read every message again.
And in the ninth message — the one I had skimmed too quickly the first time — I found it.
A line buried in a paragraph about regret and timing and things that couldn't be changed.
*The reason I told you about the other man was because I needed you to be uncertain.
I needed you to need me.
Because if you married her without any doubts, I would lose her completely.
I see that now.
I'm not proud of it.
But I need you to understand that everything I did came from a place of genuine feeling, even when the method was wrong.*
She had admitted it.
In writing.
She had fabricated the story about another man — the story that sent Cole to a paternity clinic, the story that made him doubt his own child — because she had wanted to keep him uncertain.
Keep him needing her.
Keep herself close.
I put my phone face-down on the duvet.
My daughter kicked once, hard, against my ribs.
"I know," I said quietly.
I picked the phone back up.
I screenshot every message in that folder.
I sent them to my own email.
Then I took screenshots of the screenshots and sent those to a second address I had created years ago for a work project and rarely used.
I was not going to lose this.
At half past three, my phone lit up with a text from Cole.
*Please come home.
I can't sleep.
I need to know you're okay.*
May you like
I looked at the message for a long time.
Then I put the phone back on the pillow and I lay down and I stared at the ceiling until the light outside the window began to change colour, and I thought about the word *eventually*, and what my mother had believed I would understand, and why she had thought that was a thing a person could ask for.