Chapter 3: The Woman in the Photograph

The agent's name was Dorian Hale.
He had kind eyes and a calm voice, and he looked at my mother the way someone looks at a person they thought they might never see standing upright again.
He pulled out a chair at our kitchen table.
"Sit down, Elena," he said.
"Both of you."
Mom flinched at the name.
Just slightly.
Then she sat.
Dad hadn't moved from the counter.
His knuckles were white against the edge.
"Her name is Sarah," he said.
"Her name has always been Sarah."
"Her name," Dorian said, opening the folder, "is Elena Marsh.
And eleven years ago, she watched three men walk out of a federal courthouse because the only witness willing to testify disappeared the night before the trial."
Dad stared at him.
"That witness," Dorian continued, "was her."
I was still at the top of the stairs.
Nobody had told me to come down.
Nobody had told me to stay either.
I sat on the top step and held the phone against my chest and listened.
"Elena." Dad said the name like it belonged to a stranger.
"You're telling me I've been married to a woman who doesn't exist?"
Mom looked at her hands.
"Ryan, I—"
"Eleven years." His voice cracked.
"Emily.
Our daughter.
Was any of it real?"
"All of it was real." Mom looked up.
"I am real.
I just couldn't tell you who I was."
"Why not?"
Dorian answered before she could.
"Because the man she witnessed committing a federal crjme has spent eleven years and considerable resources trying to find her.
And until seventy-two hours ago, he didn't know where she was."
The room went quiet.
Dad's hands dropped from the counter.
"Until seventy-two hours ago," he repeated slowly.
"What happened seventy-two hours ago?"
Dorian looked at him steadily.
"Someone told him."
Dad's face changed.
The broken look shifted into something else.
Something sharper.
"You think it was me."
"We don't think anything yet, Mr.
Calloway.
We have questions."
"I didn't tell anyone anything.
I didn't even know there was anything to tell." He turned to Mom.
"I didn't know, Elena.
I swear to God I didn't know."
Mom looked at him for a long moment.
"I know," she said.
"That's why I'm still in this kitchen."
I came down the stairs then.
Nobody stopped me.
Mom opened her arms and I walked into them and she held me the way she always held me after the bad nights — tight, both arms, her chin resting on top of my head.
"Is your real name really Elena?" I asked.
"Yes."
"Do I have to call you that?"
She pulled back just enough to look at my face.
"You can call me Mom," she said.
"That one was always true."
Dorian cleared his throat gently.
"I'm sorry to interrupt.
But we need to move quickly.
The man who's looking for her — who's been looking for her for eleven years — his name is Victor Crane.
And as of this morning, we have reason to believe he knows this address."
Dad straightened.
"Then why are we still standing here?"
"Because," Dorian said, sliding a second photograph across the table, "we need to know if you recognize this man.
He was photographed outside Emily's school this afternoon.
Forty minutes before she came home."
I looked at the photograph.
My stomach dropped.
May you like
I recognized him.
He was the man who had waved at me through the fence last Tuesday and asked if I knew what time school let out.