Spotlight

Chapter 4: What Emily Asked

"How many people did you tell?"

Mark blinked.

"What?"

"How many people." Emily folded her hands in her lap over the curve of her belly.

Perfectly still.

"Did you tell them it was Claire's fault.

That she was the one who couldn't have children.

How many people heard that from you."

"Emily, that isn't—"

"Your mother heard it." She nodded toward Diane.

"I heard it.

Who else."

Mark shifted his weight.

"I didn't keep a list."

"Your brother?"

A silence.

"Mark.

Did you tell your brother it was Claire?"

"We talked about it, yes."

"His wife?"

Another silence.

"Your colleagues at work?

People at the firm?"

"I may have mentioned—"

"Your friends from college who sent us a gift when we announced the pregnancy." Emily's voice didn't waver.

"The card said congratulations on finally getting your wish.

I thought that was a strange thing to write." She paused.

"Now I understand what they meant."

Across the room, Diane had sat down in one of the chairs along the wall.

She looked older than she had twenty minutes ago.

"I want to know the number," Emily said.

"I want to know how many people in our life, in my life now, were told a lie about another woman's body so that you would look like the wronged party in your divorce."

"It wasn't a lie.

The doctors said—"

"The doctors said unexplained infertility." I said it quietly.

"Both of us.

Those were the exact words.

Every time."

Emily looked at me.

"You were in those appointments."

"Every one of them."

"And the results were—"

"Shared.

Both sides.

That was always the answer." I shifted Owen to my other hip.

"Mark's motility numbers weren't strong.

Mine weren't either.

It was never one person's diagnosis.

But by the time we reached the parking lot after every appointment, it had become my problem."

The woman near the back of the room with the handbag set it down again.

She wasn't going anywhere.

None of them were.

Mark turned to face me directly.

When he spoke, his voice had a new texture.

Something harder underneath it, the way certain men sound when they've been caught and have decided that offense is the only remaining option.

"You had three years to pick up a phone," he said.

"Three years.

Those are my sons and you kept them from me for three years.

Whatever I did, whatever I said in this marriage, you don't have the right to make that call for me."

The room shifted.

I could feel it.

A few people straightened.

Because he wasn't entirely wrong, and everyone in that room knew it, and he knew they knew it, and he had just played the only card he had left.

Luke lifted his head from my shoulder.

"Mommy," he said.

Not scared.

Just checking.

"I'm here, baby," I said.

I looked at Mark.

"You're right," I said.

He hadn't expected that.

"You deserved to know," I said.

"And if you had been a different kind of man, I would have told you.

The morning you left my apartment, I was already two weeks late.

I didn't know yet.

But when I found out, I thought about calling you every day for a month." I paused.

"And then I remembered the words you used when you ended our marriage.

I remembered Thanksgiving.

I remembered the appointments, the parking lots, the way you looked at me when another treatment failed.

And I decided that my sons deserved to grow up without someone looking at them the way you looked at me."

The room was absolutely silent.

"So yes," I said.

"You deserved to know.

And I made a choice.

And I will live with that choice.

But don't stand in this room, in front of your pregnant wife, and try to make this about my failures.

You sent me that invitation.

You wrote those words.

You chose this room.

Not me."

Mark's jaw tightened.

He took one step toward me.

Diane stood up from her chair.

She didn't say anything.

She simply stood.

Between Mark and me.

He stopped.

The woman with the handbag had her phone out now.

She wasn't looking at the screen.

She was holding it at her side, loosely.

But she had taken it out.

Emily pushed herself up from her chair.

"I need some air," she said.

To no one in particular.

Then she looked at Mark.

"Don't follow me yet."

She walked toward the side door that opened onto the corridor.

She passed within a few feet of me.

She stopped.

She looked at Luke.

Then at Owen.

She reached out and very gently touched the top of Owen's head.

Just once.

He looked up at her with his dark eyes.

"Hi," he said.

"Hi," she said softly.

Then she pushed through the door and was gone.

Mark watched the door close behind her.

And for the first time since I had walked into that room, he looked like a man who understood that he had built something that was now falling on him.

But I knew Mark.

I had known him for eleven years.

And I knew that look on his face wasn't remorse.

Not yet.

May you like

It was strategy.

He was already deciding what to do next.

Related Stories

Other posts