Spotlight

Chapter 4: What Carol Knew

We sat at the kitchen table, the three of us.

Lena kept her hands wrapped around a mug Carol had put in front of her without asking — chamomile, already steeping.

A small thing.

The kind of small thing nobody else had thought to do.

Our parents hadn't come inside yet.

Through the window above the sink I could see my father still standing near the truck, talking on his phone.

My mother had sat down on the front step.

"How much do you know?" I asked Carol.

She pulled out the chair across from me and sat down.

"Enough."

"She asked me a month ago if she could stay with me for a while," Carol said.

She was looking at Lena, not me.

"After the school year ends.

She said she needed some space."

I looked at Lena.

"You didn't tell me that."

Lena shrugged one shoulder.

"I didn't want to make it a thing."

"It is a thing."

"I know." She wrapped both hands tighter around the mug.

"I just — I didn't know how to explain it without sounding ungrateful.

They feed me.

They keep the lights on.

They're not—" She stopped.

"They're not what?" I asked.

"They're not cruel.

Not the way people think of cruel.

They don't shout.

They don't—" Another stop.

"They just make you feel like you're a little less important.

Every time.

In small ways.

And then if you say anything about it, they look at you like you're inventing it."

Carol reached over and put her hand on Lena's.

"I believe you," Carol said simply.

Lena stared at the table.

Her jaw worked for a moment.

Those two words had clearly landed somewhere she wasn't ready for.

"When did it start?" I asked Carol.

"The favouritism.

When did you first notice it?"

Carol leaned back.

"Before Lena was born, if I'm honest."

"What does that mean?"

"Your parents always wanted a son the second time around.

When Lena came, your mother didn't take it well.

Not because she didn't love the baby, but because the baby wasn't what she'd planned for." Carol folded her hands on the table.

"It settled over time.

But some things that start as disappointment can become habit, and habit becomes normal, and then one day normal becomes invisible."

"They don't even see it," Lena said quietly.

"No," Carol agreed.

"I don't think they do."

The back door opened.

My mother stepped in.

She looked at the three of us at the table and stopped in the doorway, reading the room.

"What is going on in here?"

"We're talking," I said.

"About what?"

"About Lena."

My mother came in and set her hands on the back of one of the empty chairs.

She didn't sit.

"Carol, I hope you're not feeding into this.

Today has gotten completely out of hand and all I want—"

"Sit down, Diane," Carol said.

The way she said it was not unkind.

It was simply final.

My mother looked at her sister.

Something passed between them, old and deep and not entirely comfortable.

Then my mother pulled out the chair and sat.

"I'm not here to attack you," Carol said.

"I'm here because I love you and I love these girls.

Both of them."

My mother said nothing.

"Do you know what Lena asked for for her birthday?" Carol continued.

"Art supplies.

I told her—"

"She asked for three hundred dollars of art supplies because she has real talent and she's been working on her portfolio for two years.

She talked herself down to a gift card because she already knew what the answer would be."

"That's not—"

"She knew, Diane.

Before you answered her, she already knew."

My mother's hands tightened on the edge of the table.

I watched her face.

Not angry now.

Something more complicated.

"She knows things a seventeen-year-old shouldn't have to know about her own parents," Carol said.

"And today was not an accident.

Today was just the first time someone finally said it where you couldn't look away."

The room was very quiet.

Then my father appeared in the doorway behind my mother, phone in his jacket pocket.

He looked at all of us.

He looked at Lena last.

"Your grandfather called," he said to me.

His voice was careful.

Measured.

"He wants to speak to you."

The way he said it made the air in the room shift.

Carol sat up slightly.

"Why?" I asked.

My father glanced at my mother.

Something moved between them too quickly for me to catch.

May you like

"He said it's about the trust," my father said.

"He said it's about both of you."

Related Stories

Other posts