Chapter 5: David

Nathan's brother was in the groom's suite at the end of the hall.
He was still dressed for the wedding — dark gray suit, cream tie, the boutonnière Nathan had chosen for him still pinned to his lapel.
He had a glass of something in his hand that he hadn't drunk, and when the door opened and Nathan walked in carrying Lily, David stood up immediately.
One look at Nathan's face and the glass went to the table.
"What happened?
Is she—"
"Sit down, David."
David sat.
Lily had her face hidden against her father's neck.
Nathan set her gently on the small sofa in the corner, pressed a kiss to the top of her head, and crossed the room to stand in front of his brother.
He didn't sit.
He didn't pace.
He stood, and he waited, and he let the silence do the work first.
"The investigator found me," Nathan said finally.
"Martin Calloway.
Do you know that name?"
David's hand moved toward his glass.
He stopped it.
"Yes," David said.
"How long have you known he was looking for you?"
"Three weeks."
"Did you tell her?"
A pause.
Brief.
Decisive.
"Yes," David said.
Nathan exhaled through his nose.
A long, controlled breath.
"She told me it started before we met," Nathan said.
"Is that true?"
"Yes."
"And it continued."
David looked at his hands.
"Nathan—"
"I need a yes or a no."
"Yes."
"Eight months ago you ended it."
"Yes."
"You stood at my rehearsal dinner and gave a speech about what kind of man I am." Nathan's voice didn't waver.
"You shook my hand.
You told me you were proud of me."
David said nothing.
"Connor," Nathan said.
David's jaw tightened.
"You knew about the boy."
"I found out six months ago," David said.
"She told me when she ended — when I ended things.
She told me as a way of—" He stopped.
Tried again.
"She told me to keep me from saying anything to you.
If I talked, she'd tell you the boy was mine."
"Is he?"
The question landed like something dropped from a great height.
David looked up.
His eyes were red at the rims.
"No," he said.
"I don't — I'm not his father.
She told me that too.
The timing doesn't — it's not me."
"Then who?"
"Someone before you.
She said it was someone she dated before you.
She said David — she used the boy as a way to keep everyone quiet.
Me.
The mother.
Everyone."
Nathan sat down then.
Not because he needed to.
Because the room required it.
He sat on the edge of the small armchair and leaned forward with his elbows on his knees and his hands pressed together, and he looked at the floor between his feet.
Lily watched him from the sofa.
"Daddy," she said softly.
"I'm okay, bug," he said.
He wasn't.
But he said it the way fathers do.
He looked at his brother.
"She sl*pped Lily," he said.
"Lily found the phone with your photographs on it and brought it to her.
She sl*pped her across the face while Cassandra filmed it."
David stood up.
The chair scraped back.
"She what—"
"In her mother's dress, David." Nathan's voice broke once, just at the edge, and then held.
"Sophie's memory dress.
The one Lily wore to the funeral last spring."
David pressed both hands over his mouth.
He sat back down heavily.
His boutonnière bent against his lapel.
He didn't notice.
They stayed like that for a long moment.
Two brothers and a little girl and a silence that carried five years of things unsaid.
"I'm sorry," David said.
"Nathan.
I am — I have no excuse.
I have nothing to offer you except that I'm sorry."
Nathan looked at him for a long time.
"I know," he said.
"And I don't know what to do with that yet."
He stood.
Lifted Lily.
Moved toward the door.
"The relevant parties," Nathan said.
"Martin said he sent the file to the relevant parties.
I'm guessing one of them was Diane Marsh's lawyer."
"Yes," David said.
"I spoke to Calloway myself last week.
I told him to send it."
Nathan stopped.
Turned slowly.
"You helped him?"
David met his eyes.
"Someone had to."
Nathan stood in the doorway for a moment that lasted longer than it should have.
Then he walked out.
Not a word more.
Not a door slammed.
Just the quiet sound of footsteps going down the hall, and Lily's small hand patting her father's shoulder the whole way.
Behind him, in the empty groom's suite, David picked up his untouched glass and set it back down without drinking.
His phone lit up on the table.
May you like
Her name was on the screen.
He turned it face-down and didn't move.