Chapter 3: Words That Were Never Hers

Silence fell across the porch.
“Clara, go inside,” their mother ordered.
“No,” the rancher said.
“She should stay.”
Clara’s fingers closed around the doorway.
“Mother told me Eliza would never know.”
Eliza stood so quickly that her plate tipped from her lap.
The biscuits rolled across the porch boards.
“Know what?” she asked.
Her mother caught Clara by the arm.
“You’re confused.”
“I am not,” Clara said.
“You took the letter from Eliza’s desk.”
Eliza looked at the folded pages in the rancher’s hand.
“I wrote that to the county agricultural office.
I asked if anyone knew how to deepen a dry well without losing the lower pasture.”
The rancher held out the final page.
“It came to me signed with Clara’s name.”
“My name is Reid Mercer,” he continued.
“For four months, I believed I was writing to the woman who answered every question with more sense than most ranch foremen.”
Eliza stared at him.
“Four months?”
Reid removed three more letters from his coat.
“Your sister received my replies,” he said.
“But someone else answered them.”
Clara lowered her head.
“Mother made Eliza write the answers.”
“You said they were business letters,” Eliza whispered.
Her mother released Clara and stepped between them.
“And what harm was done?
Clara needed help expressing herself.
You have always been better with figures and farm matters.”
“You used my words to bring him here.”
“I brought a prosperous man to meet your sister.
This family needs security.”
Reid folded the letters slowly.
“You promised me Clara understood water rotation, cattle fever, and winter feed.”
“She understands enough to be a wife.”
“I wasn’t searching for an ornament.”
Eliza’s mother drew herself upright.
“Then perhaps you should leave.”
“Not until Eliza answers me.” Reid faced her.
“Did every idea in these letters belong to you?”
Eliza touched the edge of the supper card.
“Every word.”
Clara began to cry.
“I copied your name off the first page and replaced it with mine.
Mother said we would lose the farm if I didn’t.”
Eliza turned toward her mother.
“Why would Clara marrying Reid save the farm?”
“It is none of your concern.”
“I worked those fields while Father was ill.
I sold my jewelry to buy seed.
How is it not my concern?”
Her mother’s mouth tightened.
“Because labor does not make you an owner.”
A cane struck the floor inside the house.
Their father, Samuel, stood in the passage, one hand braced against the wall.
His face was pale, but his voice carried through the doorway.
“That is enough, Beatrice.”
Eliza hurried toward him.
“Father, you should be in bed.”
Samuel took her hand.
“And you should have been told the truth months ago.”
Beatrice blocked the doorway.
“You are not well enough for this.”
“I was well enough when I signed the deed.”
Beatrice’s face lost its color.
Eliza steadied her father.
“What deed?”
Samuel looked directly at Beatrice.
May you like
“The one giving Eliza half this farm,” he said.
“Ask your mother what she did with it.”