Chapter 9: Walter's Last Move

Sunday passed.
Eli did not go home.
He slept on Marcus's couch and lay awake most of the night with the folder on the floor beside him and the letter in its envelope on the coffee table where he could see it.
At seven in the morning Walter texted again: *Please come home.
I need to explain this properly.* At eight: *I know you're at Marcus's.* At nine, nothing.
At noon, Walter showed up.
Marcus opened the door before Eli could stop him.
Walter was standing on the small front step in his blue suit, the same one from graduation.
He looked like he hadn't slept.
That was the only thing about him that seemed honest.
"Five minutes," Walter said.
"That's all I'm asking."
Marcus looked at Eli.
Eli nodded once.
They stood in the narrow hallway, the three of them.
Marcus stayed.
"Say what you came to say," Eli said.
Walter looked at Marcus.
"Privately."
"No," Eli said.
"Say it here."
Walter's jaw worked.
Then he straightened.
"Your mother had a breakdown after Samuel d*ed.
A serious one.
She was not capable of caring for you — not at that point.
I made a decision in a crisis because I believed it was the right one for you.
I know how it looks now.
I know the method was wrong.
But the intention—"
"The intention was to keep her son from her," Eli said.
"She didn't have a breakdown.
She was in a police station filling out paperwork.
You know that.
You were the one who used it."
Walter paused.
"Her mental state in the months before Samuel was—"
"I have a letter she wrote when I was three months old," Eli said.
"I've read it.
It's the most coherent, careful, loving document I have ever seen.
That is not someone who couldn't raise a child." He kept his voice level.
"You took me because your family had money and she didn't.
Because she was alone and you weren't.
Because you could."
Walter's composure cracked, just at the surface.
"I raised you," he said.
"Eighteen years.
I was there for every single—"
"You let her think I was d*ad."
"I—"
"You hired Dennis Renner to alter my birth certificate so she could never prove otherwise.
I have the check."
Walter went very still.
"You have—"
"A photocopy of the check.
Dated November 2006.
Made out to Renner Associates.
Signed by you." Eli watched his father's face.
"The original is with an attorney in Harrisburg.
Copies are with us and with Patricia Shen, who is a civil fraud attorney and who we are meeting with tomorrow morning."
Something moved behind Walter's eyes.
He had come here thinking there was still something to manage.
The moment he understood there wasn't, it showed.
"Eli." His voice dropped.
"Whatever you're planning to do — think about what it means.
For your life.
For the family.
For—"
"For you," Eli said.
"You mean for you."
"I mean for all of us.
If this becomes a legal matter, it doesn't just touch me.
It touches everything.
Your college enrollment.
The house.
The—"
"Are you threatening me?"
Walter stopped.
"That sounded like a threat," Marcus said from the wall.
His voice was very calm.
Walter looked at Marcus.
Then back at Eli.
"I'm your father," Walter said.
"You told my mother I was d*ad," Eli said.
"On the week she buried my brother.
You had help doing it, you paid for that help, and you have let it stand for eighteen years." He opened the front door.
"We're done for today."
Walter didn't move for a moment.
He looked at his son with an expression that might have been sorrow and might have been calculation.
With Walter, Eli realized, it was not always possible to tell which one was real.
"If you go to that meeting tomorrow," Walter said, "I will have no choice but to—"
"I'll see you on the other side of it," Eli said.
Walter left.
Eli closed the door.
Marcus let out a slow breath.
"He said *I will have no choice but to*," Marcus said.
"And then he didn't finish."
"I know."
"What do you think he meant?"
Eli picked up his phone and sent a message to Patricia.
*Walter came to Marcus's address.
He said he'd have no choice but to — unfinished sentence.
Wanted me warned before tomorrow.*
Patricia's reply came in four minutes.
*Noted.
I'll have someone in the lobby at 8:45.
Come early.
Don't come alone.*
Eli put the phone down.
"He's going to try something tonight," he said.
"Or early tomorrow."
"What can he do?"
Eli thought about Ruth in Room 114 at the Carver Inn.
The suitcase packed light.
The photograph face-up on the table.
"I don't know," he said.
"But she's been alone this whole time."
He picked up his phone and called Ruth.
She picked up on the first ring.
"He came to where I'm staying," Eli said.
"Not Renner.
Walter himself.
He's running out of moves.
Is your door locked?
Chain, not just the latch?"
A short pause.
The sound of a chain sliding.
"It is now," Ruth said.
"Patricia wants us there at nine.
I'll pick you up at eight-fifteen."
"I'll be ready." A pause.
"Eli.
Are you all right?"
He thought about it.
"I think so," he said.
"I think I'm actually better than I've been in a long time.
It's strange."
"It's not strange," Ruth said quietly.
"It's what happens when you stop carrying someone else's lie."
May you like
He didn't have an answer for that.
But he stayed on the phone with her for another hour, and when he finally slept, he slept without dreaming.