Spotlight

Chapter 5: The Voice Behind the Lie

The family-services investigator introduced herself as Helen Brooks.

She asked Patricia to wait, but Patricia walked out with her attorney already on the phone.

Helen closed the restaurant door.

“Who had access to Daniel’s account?”

“No one,” Daniel said.

“At least, no one should have.”

Claire stared at the table.

“Mother knows your tablet code.”

Daniel’s head snapped toward her.

“How?”

“You used the same code at Christmas.

She watched you unlock it.”

Helen wrote something down.

“Where was the tablet today?”

“At Mother’s house,” Daniel said.

“I left it there after helping with her printer.”

Claire pressed her palms together.

“She had it beside her this morning.”

I looked at her.

“You saw it?”

“Yes.”

“Then why did you defend her?”

Claire’s eyes filled, but she did not look away.

“Because I’ve spent forty years doing what she tells me.”

Mia leaned against Daniel while Helen quietly asked Marcus to take the other children to a nearby booth.

Claire reached into her coat and removed a small tablet.

“This belongs to Ethan,” she said.

“He recorded something in the car.”

Ethan was the cousin who had spoken about Patricia not checking on Mia.

He looked toward his grandmother’s empty chair, then nodded.

“I started recording because Grandma was saying mean things.”

Claire tapped the screen.

Patricia’s voice came through the speaker.

“She needs to understand that Daniel’s kindness does not make her a Hayes.”

A child asked, “What if Mia gets scared?”

“Then perhaps she’ll learn not to demand attention.”

Another voice—Claire’s—said, “Mother, maybe we should go back.”

Patricia answered, “If you undermine me, I’ll remind everyone who pays your mortgage.”

Claire shut her eyes.

“I’m sorry.”

I pushed back from the table.

“You knew she was out there.”

“I thought Mother had gone back for her.

She told me Mia was with a security officer.”

“You never checked?”

“No.”

My knees weakened, and the edge of the table caught my hand.

Daniel moved toward me, but I held up my palm.

“Please don’t tell me everyone made a mistake.

Mia stood there asking herself why none of you came back.”

Claire stood, then stopped several feet away.

“You’re right.

I chose being afraid of Mother over protecting Mia.”

Mia watched her from Daniel’s arms.

“Aunt Claire, did you forget me?”

Claire broke.

She knelt on the restaurant floor and covered her mouth as tears ran down her face.

“No, sweetheart.

I failed you.

That is worse than forgetting.”

Mia pressed her cheek against Daniel’s shoulder.

Claire placed Ethan’s tablet on the table.

“You can give this to Helen.

I won’t delete anything, even if Mother takes the house.”

Helen accepted it.

“I’ll make a forensic copy tonight.”

Marcus opened the incident folder.

“There’s another detail.

The message changing the pickup time came from Daniel’s account at 10:14 this morning.”

Daniel unlocked his phone.

“I was driving Mia to Patricia’s house then.”

“I was sitting beside you,” I said.

“Your phone was in the cup holder.”

Claire wiped her face.

“Mother sent me a photograph at 10:16.

Daniel’s tablet is visible behind her.”

Helen turned the screen toward us.

The tablet sat on Patricia’s kitchen counter.

Its display was awake.

“That links her to the device,” Helen said.

“But we’ll still need the access records.”

Daniel put Mia down gently.

“Can you get those?”

“With your consent.”

“You have it.”

A server approached with a mug of warm milk and a plate of toast.

She set them in front of Mia.

“This is from me,” she said.

“No child should have to ask twice for food.”

Mia looked at the woman’s name tag.

“Thank you, Ruth.”

Ruth squeezed her shoulder.

“You eat every bite you want, sweetheart.”

My eyes filled.

Daniel took my hand, and I finally let him hold it.

Helen’s phone vibrated.

She read the screen twice.

“The mall’s technical department just checked the archive.

Someone called twenty minutes ago and requested that today’s parking footage be erased.”

“Who?” I asked.

May you like

Helen turned the phone toward Daniel.

“The caller gave Patricia Hayes’s name—and the private security code for the Hayes family business.”

Related Stories

Other posts