Chapter 4: The Messages on the Screen

Delia Shaw read the papers twice, then placed them beside Naomi’s untouched coffee.
“These messages came from a number registered to you.”
“They didn’t come from my phone.”
“Can you prove where you were when they were sent?”
Naomi opened her calendar.
“One was sent Tuesday at three fifteen.
I was collecting Maisie from preschool.”
“Is there a camera?”
“Over the front entrance.”
Delia tapped the page.
“Then we ask for the footage and the school’s electronic records.”
The office door opened.
Eleanor entered carrying a tablet and an old birthday card.
“I found something.”
Naomi stood.
“Where?”
“My doorbell camera.
Vanessa visited me last Thursday.”
Eleanor played the recording.
Vanessa appeared on-screen holding an empty casserole dish.
“Watch her when I go into the kitchen,” Eleanor said.
On the screen, Vanessa opened a drawer near the front door.
She removed the birthday card Naomi had given Eleanor, photographed the handwritten message, and returned it.
Delia picked up the card.
“Naomi, is this your signature?”
“Yes.”
“She had a sample.”
Eleanor lowered her eyes.
“I let her into my home.”
“You didn’t know.”
“I knew she resented you.
I did not know she would use Maisie.”
Delia copied the video.
“This helps, but it doesn’t prove she made the school form.”
A knock sounded.
Graham walked in without Vanessa.
“I want to see the evidence.”
Naomi faced him.
“Did you bring Maisie?”
“She’s with my father.”
“Why isn’t she with me?”
“Because I don’t know who is telling the truth.”
Eleanor pushed the tablet toward him.
“Your wife searched my drawer and photographed Naomi’s signature.”
Graham watched the recording.
His jaw tightened, but he did not release the tablet.
“Vanessa said she was looking for a pen.”
“Inside a closed drawer?” Eleanor asked.
“She returned the card.”
“After photographing it.”
Graham looked at Naomi.
“What about the messages?”
“Give Delia your phone.”
“No.”
“Then you don’t want the truth.”
“I want to protect Maisie.”
Naomi’s palm came down on the table.
“You took her from school using false paperwork.”
“You made every decision for four years.
Her school, her doctor, where she spent Christmas.”
“Because whenever I asked for help, you said Vanessa had plans.”
“That isn’t fair.”
“No, Graham.
What isn’t fair is making Maisie pay because you are still angry that I left you.”
His face hardened.
“You didn’t leave.
You shut me out.”
“I left because you watched Vanessa treat our daughter like an embarrassment at your wedding.”
“You humiliated my wife in front of my entire family.”
“She hid Maisie in a side room.”
“And you made sure everyone knew.”
Eleanor stepped between them.
“Stop arguing about the ballroom.
Your daughter is frightened today.”
Graham finally placed his phone on Delia’s desk.
“You have one hour.”
Delia connected it to her computer.
Several minutes later, she pointed to a message thread.
“Naomi’s supposed messages were sent as screenshots.
Vanessa forwarded them to you.”
“She said Naomi deleted the originals.”
“Then why didn’t you ask Naomi?”
Graham’s gaze dropped.
Naomi spoke quietly.
“Because believing Vanessa gave you permission to punish me.”
His chair scraped backward.
“I’m not the villain here.”
“No,” Delia said.
“But you signed a court statement without checking whether your evidence was real.”
Graham walked to the door.
“Bring Maisie to the hearing,” Naomi called after him.
He stopped but did not turn.
“The judge will decide where she goes.”
Delia’s computer chimed.
The school had sent its pickup records.
Naomi leaned over the screen.
“Does that prove I was there?”
Delia opened the file, and her expression changed.
“It proves you collected Maisie on both days Vanessa said you abandoned her.”
“Then we have her.”
“Not yet.” Delia turned the next page toward Naomi.
May you like
“Vanessa filed another statement ten minutes ago.”
It claimed Naomi was planning to take Maisie out of the country.