Spotlight

Chapter 4: The Accusation That Changed Everything

Mrs.

Cole closed the music-room door.

“Malik’s mother was Naomi Carter,” she said.

“She studied under Mr.

Vale during his first year here.”

Malik stared at the teacher.

“You knew her?”

Vale folded his arms.

“I taught hundreds of students.”

“You remembered her melody.”

“I remember stolen work.”

Mrs.

Cole pulled out her phone.

“Naomi entered that melody in the same regional competition.

She was expected to win.”

Vale’s face hardened.

“You were a receptionist.

You knew nothing about judging.”

“I knew Naomi left my desk in tears after you told her the judges had rejected her.”

Malik’s shoulders dropped.

“She never told me.”

A district security officer entered and stood beside the door.

Evelyn pointed to a chair.

“Mr.

Vale, sit down.”

“My attorney will have plenty to say about this.”

“Then call your attorney.

You are still not leaving with school records.”

Vale sat and dialed.

Malik’s father arrived moments later, breathless and pale.

“Malik!”

“Dad, I’m all right.”

Daniel Carter wrapped both arms around his son.

When he saw Vale, he released Malik and stepped forward.

“You put your hands on my boy?”

Vale raised his phone.

“Threaten me, Mr.

Carter, and my attorney will hear every word.”

Daniel stopped.

Malik caught his sleeve.

“Dad, he says Mom stole the melody.”

Daniel’s face changed.

“Who said that?”

“I said Malik submitted work written by Naomi,” Vale replied.

“Competition rules require original material.”

Daniel looked at the floor.

Malik’s voice trembled.

“Dad, why aren’t you answering him?”

Evelyn placed the application pages on the piano.

“Mr.

Carter, did Naomi compose the opening?”

“She wrote eight measures,” Daniel said.

“She used to play them when Malik couldn’t sleep.”

“And Malik disclosed that,” Tessa said.

“I saw the credit page.”

Vale spoke into his phone.

“Did you hear that?

The father admitted the composition wasn’t original.”

Daniel’s head came up.

“My son built an entire piece around eight measures his mother gave him.

He never hid it.”

“Yet the judges didn’t receive the disclosure,” Vale said.

“Until the investigation is complete, the award cannot stand.”

The attorney’s voice came through the phone.

“Dr.

Brooks, preserve all records.

My client is filing a formal misconduct complaint against Malik Carter for fraudulent submission.”

“You’re blaming him for a page you handled?” Evelyn asked.

“I’m invoking district procedure.”

A second call flashed on Evelyn’s phone.

She answered on speaker.

“Evelyn, this is Superintendent Hale.

Mr.

Vale’s attorney contacted the board.”

“That was fast.”

“The board chair has ordered the award held and Malik removed from tomorrow’s state performance until we review the plagiarism allegation.”

Malik’s black case slipped from his hands.

Daniel caught it before it struck the floor.

“You’re taking me out?” Malik asked.

“Before you even check the files?”

“I’m sorry,” Hale said.

“The order came from Chairwoman Mercer.”

Tessa frowned.

“Mercer?

Is she related to Caleb Mercer?”

Vale’s mouth curved into a small smile.

“She’s his grandmother,” Mrs.

Cole said.

Evelyn ended the call.

“So the student you wanted to receive Malik’s award is the board chair’s grandson.”

“Caleb earned his chance,” Vale replied.

“No,” Malik said.

“You tried to give him mine.”

Vale stood as the security officer opened the door.

“This conversation is over.

The award is frozen, your performance is canceled, and by tomorrow the board will know whose music you really used.”

Daniel put a hand on Malik’s shoulder, but Malik pulled away.

“You always told me Mom believed in my music,” he said.

“Was that true—or was that another thing everyone kept from me?”

Daniel’s lips parted, but no answer came.

A boy stood on the other side of the open doorway.

His face was white, and a music folder shook in his hand.

It was Caleb Mercer.

May you like

“Malik,” he said, “Mr.

Vale didn’t tell you the worst part.”

Related Stories

Other posts