Chapter 6: # CHAPTER 6: What Karen Never Said

I sat in the car in Vanessa's driveway for four minutes without starting the engine.
There was a particular kind of sentence that was designed to do only one thing — break your trust in the people standing next to you, so you'd have nowhere left to go.
Vanessa had just used one.
I knew what it was.
I could see the shape of it clearly.
That didn't stop it from working.
I drove back to Karen's.
She was in the kitchen making sandwiches for the kids when I walked in.
She looked at my face and put the knife down.
"What happened?"
"Vanessa says she's been recording the house for six months."
"Okay." Karen's voice was level.
"That's a problem for Dennis."
"She also said to ask you what you said to her at Claire's funeral.
And where you were the night Claire died."
Karen's hands went flat on the counter.
"She said that."
"Yes."
The refrigerator hummed.
Outside, Mason and Lily were visible through the window.
Mason was teaching Lily how to roll a ball to the dog.
"Sit down," Karen said.
I sat.
She poured two glasses of water, set one in front of me, and kept one in her hands.
She stood at the counter and looked at the window for a moment.
"Claire called me the night before she went into the hospital," she said.
"You were working the overnight.
She called me at about eleven and said she felt wrong.
Not sick-wrong.
Just — wrong.
She asked me if I'd come over."
"You never told me that."
"No." Karen looked at me.
"I didn't."
"Why?"
"Because I didn't go." Her voice didn't waver, but her grip on the glass tightened.
"I'd been up since five that morning.
I had a presentation at seven the next day.
I told her she was probably just tired and to call the doctor in the morning if she still felt off." She paused.
"She said okay.
She said sorry for bothering me.
Those were the last real words she said to me."
The kitchen was very still.
"By the time you called me the next afternoon, she was already in the ICU."
I looked at my glass of water.
"Karen—"
"At the funeral," she said, "Vanessa came up to me.
I don't know how she knew.
Maybe Claire had told her, or maybe she'd overheard something.
But she stood very close to me and said, very quietly, 'She called you that night, didn't she.' Not a question.
Just a statement." Karen set her glass down.
"I didn't answer her.
I walked away.
But I've been watching her use it ever since.
Every time she needed leverage, every time she wanted you not to ask questions — she kept that in her back pocket."
I sat with everything she'd just said.
"You should have told me."
"Yes." No deflection.
No excuse.
"I should have.
I've lived with that for three years, Michael.
Not a day goes by." Her voice thickened slightly, then steadied.
"But Vanessa didn't bring it up to help you understand me.
She brought it up so you'd doubt me right now, tonight, when she needs you to be alone."
I already knew that.
I'd known it in the driveway.
Knowing it and feeling it were two different things.
"I'm not going anywhere," Karen said.
"Not until Lily is safe.
After that, you can be as angry at me as you need to be."
Mason appeared in the back doorway.
"Dad?
Lily's hungry.
Can we have sandwiches?"
"Yes, buddy." I cleared my throat.
"In two minutes."
He went back outside.
I looked at my sister.
"Finish making the sandwiches," I said.
"We'll talk more tonight after they're asleep."
She turned back to the counter.
Her shoulders dropped, just slightly.
My phone buzzed.
A number I didn't recognize.
I answered it.
"Mr.
Carter?
This is Sandra Reyes from Child Protective Services.
I've received a referral regarding your daughter, Lily Carter.
I'd like to set up a home visit and speak with you as soon as possible."
"When can you come?"
"Tomorrow morning, if that works.
Nine o'clock."
"I'll be here." I gave her Karen's address.
I hung up and looked at the window.
Lily was sitting in the grass now, holding Mr.
Bear up so he could see the dog.
She was laughing.
Something in my chest came loose just slightly — not relief.
Not yet.
But the first small sign that the ground under her was beginning to solidify.
Then my phone buzzed again.
Vanessa.
*I spoke to my mother tonight.
She's flying in from Phoenix.
She's going to testify about your temper if this goes any further.
Think carefully, Michael.*
---
May you like
* * *
---
Related Stories