Chapter 4: What Brooke Found in March

I kept my hands flat on the tablecloth.
"What does the letter say?" I asked.
Sienna looked at Grandma Rose.
Grandma Rose looked back at her with the specific patience of a woman who has outlasted many difficult conversations and is prepared to outlast this one.
"Tell her," Grandma said.
"Whatever you know."
Sienna took a breath.
"Your mother wrote it by hand.
Eight pages.
Brooke showed it to me once — just once — back in April.
She was upset.
She wanted me to tell her she was right to be angry." A pause.
"I couldn't do that."
"Why not?"
"Because the letter wasn't what Brooke said it was." Sienna's hands moved against each other on the table.
"Brooke told me your mother had cut her out of the will.
That she'd left everything to you because you'd always been the favorite.
That it was unfair, that your mother had always treated her differently, that she deserved to fight it."
"And?"
"And I read the letter myself.
It wasn't about cutting Brooke out." Sienna stopped.
"It was about you."
The pianist moved into a slower chord progression.
Two tables over, someone laughed at something and it sounded very far away.
"What do you mean it was about me?" I said.
"Your mother wrote it explaining why she made the decisions she made.
About the house.
About the money she'd been setting aside.
About why it was going to be split the way it was split." Sienna looked at me steadily.
"She explained that she'd always known Brooke struggled with the situation.
With you being in the family.
She said she loved Brooke completely.
But she wanted to make sure that when she was gone, you would be taken care of.
Because she was worried Brooke might — her exact words were — *find reasons not to.*"
Grandma Rose's hand came down on the table.
Not hard.
Just down.
"She knew," Grandma said.
Not to me.
To herself.
"Brooke's argument," Sienna continued, "was that the will proved your mother loved you more.
That's how she framed it to her lawyers.
To Ethan.
To me." She paused.
"But that's not what the letter says.
It says your mother loved you both.
It says she was trying to protect you specifically because she was afraid of exactly what happened tonight."
I looked at the folded place card still sitting upright in its brass holder.
"Where is the letter now?" I asked.
"Brooke has it.
She keeps it in a lockbox at the house.
I've told her twice to let you see it." Sienna's voice dropped.
"She said if you ever found out it existed, she'd say I made it up."
Tyler had gone very still beside me.
He was looking at Sienna the way people look at someone when they're deciding whether to believe them and have already decided.
"You're telling me now," I said.
"At her wedding."
"I'm telling you now because she pulled your chair out from under you in front of your grandmother." Sienna's voice was quiet but it was not soft.
"I've known Brooke for eleven years.
I have defended her more times than I can count.
But what she did tonight — she planned it.
She told me two weeks ago she'd seat you near the kitchen.
I thought she was venting.
I didn't think she'd actually—" She stopped.
"I should have said something then."
The white-paneled door opened.
Brooke came through it first.
Ethan followed, one step behind.
His jacket pocket square was gone.
He'd been holding it, probably, working it in his hand.
He did that when he was angry.
I had seen it once before, at Thanksgiving, when someone said something unkind about his mother.
Brooke's eyes found Sienna across the room.
Sitting at table nine.
Across from me.
She crossed the ballroom floor in her ivory satin like the crowd was something she was moving through rather than among.
She stopped at the edge of the table.
"We should finish this conversation somewhere private," she said.
Her voice had the quality of controlled weather.
"All of us."
"I'm comfortable here," Grandma Rose said.
"Grandma Rose—"
"I said I'm comfortable here, Brooke."
Brooke looked at Sienna.
Her voice dropped to something that was technically still a sentence but functioned as a warning.
"I want to talk to you later."
"I know," Sienna said.
Ethan put his hand on the back of a chair.
Not sitting.
Just holding it.
"Brooke.
Tell Claire about the letter."
The table went still.
Brooke's expression didn't break.
But something behind it did.
A small structural thing.
Like a wall that looked solid until you noticed the hairline running through it.
"This isn't the time," she said.
"You've had eight months," Ethan said.
"How much more time do you need?"
She turned to face him fully and her voice was very low.
"Do not do this here."
"You did this here." He gestured at the room, the tables, the empty space where my chair had been.
"You chose here.
So here we are."
Brooke's arms folded across her bodice again.
The same position as before.
Her wedding jewelry caught the light.
"Fine," she said.
Her eyes moved to me.
"The letter exists.
It's from Mom.
I found it in the house when I was cleaning out the back bedroom in March.
Yes, it discusses the will." Her chin came up.
"And yes, she left you the larger share.
The house, the savings account, the jewelry.
Because apparently thirty-one years of being the firstborn daughter wasn't enough, but you—" Her voice stopped itself.
"You were always going to get more.
And I have spent eight months trying to accept that."
"That's not what the letter says," Sienna said quietly.
Brooke's head turned to her.
Slow.
Precise.
"Be very careful," she said.
"I read it," Sienna said.
"In your kitchen.
In April.
You handed it to me and asked me what I thought." She didn't look away.
"I told you then that you were reading it wrong."
The champagne glass someone had set near the table's edge tipped, caught by a passing waiter before it fell.
Nobody moved.
Then Brooke said, very quietly, "Mom chose her over me.
She always did.
And I am so tired of pretending that didn't happen."
The room heard it.
She hadn't meant them to.
But the room was listening.
And across the table, Grandma Rose closed her eyes for exactly three seconds.
When she opened them, she looked at Brooke with something that was not anger and not pity.
"I have something to tell you," Grandma said.
May you like
"Both of you.
And I should have said it a long time ago."