Spotlight

Chapter 5: The Things a Mother Knows

Sarah arrived at the station at 10:30 AM with a coffee I hadn't asked for and a look on her face I recognized from every bad call we had ever taken together — the one that meant she already knew more than she wanted to and was deciding how much to say.

She set the coffee in front of me without a word.

I wrapped both hands around it.

"Lily's with Officer Nguyen in the family room," she said.

"She's doing a puzzle.

A big one.

Horses."

"She likes horses."

"I know.

I brought one from the supply closet." Sarah sat down across from me.

"Laura."

"I know."

"Fourteen months."

"I know."

She leaned forward.

"How are you sitting here this calmly?"

"Because if I stop being calm, I stop being useful.

And right now being useful is the only thing I have."

Sarah was quiet for a moment.

Then she put her hand flat on the table between us — not touching me, just there.

It was enough.

Detective Ramos returned to the room at 10:45 and informed me that Douglas Prewitt had been located at a motel off Interstate 10.

He was in custody.

His phone had been seized.

The calls from Mark's black phone matched Prewitt's records exactly, including two calls placed in the forty-eight hours before that morning.

"He's talking," Ramos said.

"Prewitt is cooperating.

He says your husband contacted him thirteen months ago through a referral from a private forum.

He was paid in three installments.

Cash.

The last installment was paid four days ago."

"What forum?"

"We're working on that."

"He say anything about Evelyn?"

Ramos set a printed page on the table and slid it toward me.

It was a text message pulled from Prewitt's phone.

Sent to Mark's black number two days ago.

*Everything is set.

Tuesday morning.

Confirmed with E.*

E.

Evelyn.

She hadn't been dragged into this at the last minute.

She had been confirming the schedule two days before it happened.

"She knew the exact timeline," I said.

"Yes."

Sarah made a sound beside me that she quickly turned into a cough.

I looked at the message for a long moment and then slid it back.

"Has she been formally charged?"

"She's being processed now.

Her attorney has already been contacted."

"What's she saying?"

Ramos paused.

"She's saying she was trying to protect her son.

That you were planning to leave Mark and take Lily, and that you had been threatening to expose financial irregularities in his firm."

Sarah's jaw tightened.

I felt something go very still inside me.

"I never threatened him," I said.

"I didn't know about any financial irregularities."

"We know that.

But it explains something else we found on the black phone." Ramos opened his folder.

"There are voice memos.

Three of them.

Recorded in your home over the past six weeks.

We believe the phone was placed somewhere in the main living area during that time."

He let that sit.

"He was recording our conversations," I said.

"Looking for something to use.

To discredit you, if it came to that.

Or to build a narrative that justified his actions."

"There's nothing on those recordings he could use."

"No," Ramos said simply.

"There isn't."

I thought about the past six weeks.

The dinners.

The evenings on the couch.

The bedtime routines.

Mark reading to Lily in her room while a phone hidden somewhere nearby recorded the sound of it.

"Can I hear them?" I asked.

"Not yet.

They're part of the active evidence chain."

I nodded.

At 11:20 AM, my phone rang.

Unknown number.

I looked at Ramos.

"It won't be him," he said.

"He's in holding."

I answered.

"Laura." Evelyn's voice.

Not the filtered voice from the phone call this morning.

Something rawer.

"Laura, listen to me.

You need to understand something before this goes any further."

"Evelyn.

You're calling me from police custody."

"They gave me five minutes.

Laura — Mark is not a bad man.

He made one terrible mistake and I—"

"He modified our gas line, Evelyn.

Lily was supposed to be in that house."

Silence.

"Lily was—" Her voice fractured.

Just for a moment.

"That wasn't— Mark told me you would take her to work with you.

That she wouldn't—"

"He told you she wouldn't be home."

"Yes."

"And you believed him."

The silence this time was different.

"Evelyn," I said.

"Your son wrote to you eight months ago and told you Lily would be in the house.

And that it would be cleaner that way.

I read the message.

I have a copy of the message."

Nothing.

No sound at all on the other end of the line.

"That call is being monitored," I said.

"You should stop talking now."

The line went d*ad.

Sarah was staring at me.

"She didn't know," I said quietly.

"About Lily.

Or she convinced herself she didn't.

One of the two."

"Does it matter?"

I thought about the second gas can.

Evelyn's hands on it.

Her steady walk toward the back of my house.

May you like

"No," I said.

"It really doesn't."

Related Stories

Other posts