Spotlight

Chapter 8: The Last Card He Played

He went to Dorothy.

Not to her house — the patrol car made that impossible.

He called her.

Dorothy's phone rang at seven-forty in the morning.

She didn't recognize the number.

She answered it because she always answered, because eighty-three years of life had taught her that unknown numbers could mean anything — a doctor's office, a wrong turn, someone who needed help.

"Dorothy." His voice, through the phone.

Still calm.

Still warm.

The same voice that had told her he was worried about her living alone.

She told me later that she almost hung up.

That her finger moved to the button.

But something in her held on — not because she trusted him, but because she wanted to hear what he would say when his back was against the wall.

She pressed the speaker button.

And she set her phone on the kitchen table, went to the drawer, and pulled out the small voice recorder Patricia had given her four days earlier.

She pressed record.

"I know things look bad right now," Alex said.

"I know what people are telling you about me.

But Dorothy — you know me.

You know who I actually am."

Dorothy said nothing.

"I made mistakes," he said.

"I moved too fast.

The papers, the account — I should have handled it differently.

I know that." A breath.

"But everything I did, I did because I care about you.

You were alone.

You were lonely.

I saw that."

"You saw an opportunity," Dorothy said, quietly and clearly.

A pause.

"Dorothy—"

"You saw a lonely old woman with a paid-off house and no family close by.

And you were very kind to me for just long enough."

"That's not what happened."

"You took nine thousand, four hundred dollars from my account," she said.

"You told me it was utility payments."

"I was going to pay it back.

I was having a hard month—"

"You have had three hard months," Dorothy said.

"In Georgia too."

Silence.

"I spoke with a woman named Susan Delaney," Dorothy continued.

"She told me about the other women.

She told me about the one who passed away before the case could be filed." A pause.

"How old was she?"

Nothing from his end.

"How old was she, Alex?"

"Dorothy, I'm asking you to—"

"I want you to tell me one true thing," she said.

"One true thing, before this is over.

How old was she?"

A very long pause.

"Eighty-six," he said at last.

"Older than me," Dorothy said.

"Yes."

"And did you care about her too?

The way you cared about me?"

His voice, when it came, had shed something.

The smoothness was still there but underneath it something raw had opened up.

"I told myself I did," he said.

"Every time."

"I know," Dorothy said.

"That's the saddest part of all of this."

Another pause.

Then his tone shifted — sharpened, the warmth burning off like morning frost.

"If you cooperate with them, I will tell everyone you consented to everything.

I will tell them you asked me to move in.

I'll say you told me you wanted to leave the house to me because your daughter never visits.

I'll say it on the stand and I will make them believe me, because I am very good at being believed."

Dorothy's hand, she told me later, was completely steady on the recorder.

"Yes," she said.

"You are.

But not this time."

She ended the call.

She stopped the recording.

She picked up her phone and called Patricia.

The recording reached Garrett's desk within the hour.

By noon, the DA's office had reviewed it.

By three in the afternoon, an arrest warrant had been issued.

Alex Mercer was taken into custody at a gas station twelve miles outside of town at four fifty-seven PM.

He was driving toward the state line.

His rusted sedan had a duffle bag in the back seat and two prepaid phones in the glove compartment.

One of the phones had a contacts list with four names on it.

All four were women.

All four had addresses beside their names.

All four were over seventy-five years old.

When Garrett called me with the details, I was sitting on Dorothy's porch.

She was in the chair beside me with a cup of tea and the late afternoon settling around us like it always had — quiet, familiar, unhurried.

I told her what Garrett had said about the phones.

She looked out at the street.

The bird feeder swayed slightly in the breeze.

"Four more women," she said.

"Yes."

"We got to them before he did."

"Yes."

She was quiet for a moment.

"Good," she said.

That was all.

May you like

Just that one word, sitting solid and plain and complete in the air between us.

Then she reached over and topped up my tea from the pot she'd brought outside, and we sat there together while the afternoon went about its business, and for the first time in a month the street felt like itself again.

Related Stories

Other posts